I have to agree, traditional Italian Pizza is much better then the Americanized version. But I like Fluffy crust more, if the dough is made right and it tastes good then I prefer having the Fluffy crust. Any remaining fluffy crust I have can be dipped in Marinara sauce.
But if the crust is ok and not to big in flavor then I would prefer thin crust, because then the dough has all the flavor from the toppings. So over all, I like both. It just depends on the flavor of the dough and how much love and care was put into it. Now I am hungry...