ForumsThe TavernShould marching band be considered a sport?

16 1602
soccerdude2
offline
soccerdude2
1,718 posts
1,035

Coming from someone who has had two bandies in their family, the big question looms: Is marching band a sport? I myself play soccer (herp derp) and my brother does cross country, but both of my sisters have done/do marching band. My brother and I both believe it isn't; my sisters believe it is. It seems to me that most people who do marching band believe it is the most intense sport in the world and most people who don't do it believe it's a non-sport for weenies. Or they just believe the actions done in marching band don't qualify as sport-like. But I want your opinion. What do you think?

  • 16 Replies
TheMostManlyMan
offline
TheMostManlyMan
5,600 posts
4,985

No, I've been in a fife and drum core which is close enough and I'd just say no because it's not exactly competitive. There are also no teams, no scoring so you would have to do quite a bit to it for it to be anywhere close to a sport.

R2D21999
online
R2D21999
18,224 posts
8,700

I'd say no because bands don't have special types of balls and it doesn't include running(it would be caohs if it had running).

Bronze
offline
Bronze
2,448 posts
1,155

I'll say it is. It takes skill, and you have to work with a team. I don't know how much athleticism it takes, but you do have to lug heavy equipment around for awhile.

rayoflight3
offline
rayoflight3
440 posts
10

I never understood why people get riled up by a word like "sport." Does it really matter if whatever you do (marching band, cheer leading, etc.) is considered a sport or not? If you like doing it, keep on going and forget what others think. Are you really going to derive some sort of satisfaction in convincing people your activity is a sport?

collimore
offline
collimore
46 posts
905

I don't think it should be considered a sport but I've done it before and can appreciate how hard it is. Marching and playing is not as easy as it looks... But saying it's a sport is kinda overdoing it. I play sports too and wouldn't consider it one of them.

xXxDAPRO89xXx
offline
xXxDAPRO89xXx
6,871 posts
16,160

Definetly not. Walking doesn't classify something as a sport lol.
But know. It's not really physical like (most) sports...

zeus999
offline
zeus999
34 posts
1,545

Well there are a whole bunch of less sport like sports considered a sport, so really it only matters if people think it is. Judging by the responses I'd say no.

tegan190
offline
tegan190
805 posts
80

I never understood why people get riled up by a word like "sport." Does it really matter if whatever you do (marching band, cheer leading, etc.) is considered a sport or not? If you like doing it, keep on going and forget what others think. Are you really going to derive some sort of satisfaction in convincing people your activity is a sport?


It's not about "deriving satisfaction" from it. It's about it being considered a sport so it can be aired on sports channels or even have tournaments for it.

Also, no one can say it's not a sport because it's not physical, there's many sports that don't require someone to be athletic. Like golf and professional shooting or whatever you call it =P
RawrMan57
offline
RawrMan57
14 posts
65

I would say no, it is not.
It is about as much a sport as chess.

soccerdude2
offline
soccerdude2
1,718 posts
1,035

I really don't think Golf should be considered a sport either but that's another discussion altogether.

And yes, I do think some amount of athletic ability needs to be factored in the equation.

killersup10
offline
killersup10
2,784 posts
2,490

Not really a sport...it is a side-sport. One that is alot less frequent, and in today's society is not "physical" enough to be a "real sport"

rayoflight3
offline
rayoflight3
440 posts
10

It's not about "deriving satisfaction" from it. It's about it being considered a sport so it can be aired on sports channels or even have tournaments for it.


I'm talking about people in general though, not professionals. People who wouldn't be good enough to be on TV anyway. And you can have tournaments, competitions, etc. for anything. Society does not consider playing the piano a sport, but there are still plenty of opportunities to test your talent and hard work against others. It seems like people feel better about themselves when they're convinced they play a sport and others don't, and that's something I cannot understand.
letsgome_gome
offline
letsgome_gome
804 posts
315

yes because you march for a long time with extra weight, and no because it is not athletic ability to create noise.

IAgreeWithYou
offline
IAgreeWithYou
531 posts
125

Marching bands are srs business.

Also, everything that you don't know and have not tried seems so easy...and then you try it...

I'd say it is a sport but not a traditional sport that people would watch because of the lack of competitive nature.

handlerfan
offline
handlerfan
194 posts
0

I think that marching band is more performing art than sport. It;s more about entertainment than a sport which is about achieving the aims of the game better than the competition.

Showing 1-15 of 16