ForumsPopular MediaThree Kingdoms.

27 2853
SSTG
online
SSTG
12,645 posts
9,915

Many years ago, there was a strategy game called Romance of the Three Kingdoms on the NES (Nintendo Entertainment System).
As soon as I discovered it I haven't stopped playing it.
Then came 2,3,4,5,... and so on.
I was so interested in the story that I ended up buying the novel.
Since I'm not Asian, I got the unabridged translation by Moss Robert in 4 volumes.
There are so many characters I like such as Guan Yu, Liu Bei, Zhao Yun, Zhuge Liang, just to name a few.

Anyway I was aware that a TV series was made about it but I never imagined it'll be available to watch on YouTube!

Three Kingdoms part 1

The series is very well made and the characters are realistic.
The battles, duels, plots and schemes made by the advisers and their masters are incredible! I'm now on episode 73.
As anyone seen it?

I'd like to discuss about it if some people are interested.

My first point would be that Guan Yu, used to be my favorite but when he got older he became arrogant and careless so my admiration for him went downhill. Even though the series is great, I noticed a difference. Wasn't Guan Yu killed by Cao Cao in the novel? If so then why does he get trapped by Lu Meng (Sun Quan's general) in the series?
I read the book a long time ago so I could be wrong.

  • 27 Replies
pangtongshu
offline
pangtongshu
9,995 posts
3,285

As anyone seen it?


When my computer gets fixed I hope to find some time to start watching it
(computer is also reason for lack of response to message on my profile..don't question my logic).

Wasn't Guan Yu killed by Cao Cao in the novel? If so then why does he get trapped by Lu Meng (Sun Quan's general) in the series?


The Wu forces essentially betrayed the Shu forces by teaming up with Wei to take out Guan Yu and capture the Jing province. The forces were lead by Cao Ren from Wei and Lu Meng from Wu (primarily), and it was Lu Meng who was the reason for Guan Yu's death.
[Note: Guan Yu was trying to escape but ended up trapped by Lu Meng's men, was killed by a few soldiers after he fell into a trap]
SSTG
online
SSTG
12,645 posts
9,915

The Wu forces essentially betrayed the Shu forces by teaming up with Wei to take out Guan Yu and capture the Jing province. The forces were lead by Cao Ren from Wei and Lu Meng from Wu (primarily), and it was Lu Meng who was the reason for Guan Yu's death.
[Note: Guan Yu was trying to escape but ended up trapped by Lu Meng's men, was killed by a few soldiers after he fell into a trap]

Both sides didn't dare killing Guan Yu because they knew that once Liu Bei and Zhang Fei learned about it, they would start a more aggressive war against them. If it weren't for that coward Pang De who wounded Guan Yu with a poisoned arrow, Lu Meng would have had a hard time getting him.
Seeing that his son Guan Ping was dead defending him and that he couldn't fight anymore with both arms, he slit his own throat with his Dragon spear!

After Lu Meng brought his head to Sun Quan, he himself died. They say he went crazy but I think he was poisoned by Sun Quan's order for disobeying his order to take Jing only but not to kill Guan Yu.
pangtongshu
offline
pangtongshu
9,995 posts
3,285

Both sides didn't dare killing Guan Yu because they knew that once Liu Bei and Zhang Fei learned about it, they would start a more aggressive war against them. If it weren't for that coward Pang De who wounded Guan Yu with a poisoned arrow, Lu Meng would have had a hard time getting him.
Seeing that his son Guan Ping was dead defending him and that he couldn't fight anymore with both arms, he slit his own throat with his Dragon spear!

After Lu Meng brought his head to Sun Quan, he himself died. They say he went crazy but I think he was poisoned by Sun Quan's order for disobeying his order to take Jing only but not to kill Guan Yu.


That's how the movie did it? Because that is in now way what happened in the book or in actual events.
SSTG
online
SSTG
12,645 posts
9,915

That's how the movie did it? Because that is in now way what happened in the book or in actual events.

Yeah I thought they were following the book until the last few episodes where I noticed some difference. I'm about to watch episode 73 now.
SSTG
online
SSTG
12,645 posts
9,915

What, only pang and me are fans of Three Kingdoms? :O

SSTG
online
SSTG
12,645 posts
9,915

I've watched the entire series!
I didn't like Sima Yi because he was Zhuge Liang's nemesis but after watching the whole series I don't dislike him as much.
Considering how the Cao family treated him all his life, it's amazing how he was able to survive and outsmart them at the end.

I think I'll re read Three Kingdoms again since there were some difference in the TV Series, I want to find them all out.

daydreamer01
offline
daydreamer01
442 posts
370

i'm really into the three kingdoms period i haven't
seen the show though

SSTG
online
SSTG
12,645 posts
9,915

i'm really into the three kingdoms period i haven't
seen the show though

If it's still available on YouTube, I recommend watching it, it's amazing!
daydreamer01
offline
daydreamer01
442 posts
370

ok will do sometime

daydreamer01
offline
daydreamer01
442 posts
370

have you seen the red cliff film

i like it a lot but i have only watch the parts 1 and 2
edited into one dvd release

SSTG
online
SSTG
12,645 posts
9,915

have you seen the red cliff film

No I haven't.
daydreamer01
offline
daydreamer01
442 posts
370

its about the naval battle between the kingdoms shu and wu against wei

from what i understand its disputed whether or not
its fact or myth

Zhuge Liang used his understanding of the wind clouds and weather
to set the Wei fleet ablaze

SSTG
online
SSTG
12,645 posts
9,915

its about the naval battle between the kingdoms shu and wu against wei

Cool! Zhuge Liang and Zhao Yun are my two favorite characters in Three Kingdoms.
daydreamer01
offline
daydreamer01
442 posts
370

i like both of them a lot too

i have a lot to learn about it all
and i haven't even read the novel yet

but i think i can keep up pretty well so just let me know
if ya ever want to chat about THE ROMANCE OF THREE KINGDOMS

partydevil
offline
partydevil
5,168 posts
4,560

thank you so much!! ive been looking for a new serie to watch. and i loved the whole setting of Romance of the Three Kingdoms. from both the NES, SNES series, aswell as the dynasty warriors series. i'm not so much of a reader, so i never got to reading the actual novel... is this series closely based on the novel? or is it like dynasty warriors only been used as a guideline?

No I haven't.

Red Cliff is mainly about 1 battle.. i forgot the battle name but it's about the 1 where wei's naval was burned down by wu and shu.
Showing 1-15 of 27