You know what I always wanted to see in an ArmorGames intro? The swords leaving the shield and slizicing and dizicing up the background to reveal "ArmorGames.com" somehow.
I back up Deviodless idea because that just sounds that it would look really cool and it would be very original. It makes me wish that I knew stuff about making game stuff because I would want to crate that thing.
Well, that is more or less along the lines of what I was thinking. In my mind I pictured both of them coming out and just being in a flurry. Kinda like when two cartoon characters fight, Or the Tazmanian Devil when it spins. After they return to the shield, right where armorgames.com comes out, something to the effect of ripped, torn and cut fabriv or paper fall away revealing the logo. But kinda still in the ripped/torn look.