Well, personally I do not like the idea of this topic, because if you say that moderator A is the best, it is somewhat disrespectful of moderator B. For example, if you say the Carlie is the best, then you might insult Asherlee. I think that his site has good mods in general and I prefer to leave it at that.
Well they kind of each have something that they're good at that got them to being a Mod. Carlie has been on the site for a long time and she's friends with somebody that help create this site. Asherlee, she is deticated to do stff, and knows her stuff. Take that "Sticky" topic she maded for an example. Dank, is the person you go to if you have a question about gaming or programming. He just seems to know a lot about that kind of stuff. Together they make a pretty well rounded group of Mods, so I can't really pick between them.
Sorry guys, but ubertuna is right, it may end up being offensive to one person or another. And I agree with nick_coolhaha, we are a well rounded group, each with different qualities that help with moderation.
But because this may end up being offensive, I am going to lock it.