Depends on which versions we're talking about. If we're talking about current versions, then Sonic... should be shot. Seriously. He's betrayed us hardcore fans over and over again and sold out to the audience of 8-year-olds. I'd have to go with Link on that one. But if we're talking classic versions... Oh, that's a toughy, but I'll go with Sonic. Sonic 2 was probably my most played game growing up.