Forums → The Tavern → Whats up with merits???
Ok im not mad at how they grade comments for merits or anything but its how they give them out. I've left all sorts of merit worthy comments on new and old games and i've only gotton one. The merit recognition place doesnt really do much. Awhile ago i saw a comment that got meritted and it said somthing like this, "the game wasn't very good beacuse the graphics were pretty bad and so were the controlls. i think that they nedd to fix that."
now idk about you but that is not a merit worthy comment. now im not complaining but when merits are givin out theyre not always to the right comments. So i hope some of mine and other peoples good comments can be noticed and we can all get som more merits.
- 18 Replies
I agree, I left one that was longer and better wrtten than this other one that became a merit.
Just because you type a long comment doesn't mean you deserve a merit ..
But I'm really not worried about them, since I don't really care what people think about my comments.
Yeah i agree with KING. Just because they're long doesn't mean that they're good. To get a merit worthy comment you should say what they should change and keep in a sequal.
I feel that my comments are always watched and if I don't get a merit, I proboly didn't do something up to par, but why would that get merited?
Sorry for the double post but i just realized this is in tavern, this should go in support
no it wasn't for guiding and stuff. it was to tel poeple some of the things that have been goin on for the whole meriting system.
and short comments are bad comments and long comments aren't always good comments but if you want a merit then thwey should be pretty long.
Are you saying that you posted a comment on the MeritRecognition page, and it was nominating you? Because if so you are not allowed to do that. Just to let you know.
no i didnt mean that. i no im not supposed to do that. lol. but the meritrecognition place doesnt really seem to give alot of pople merits. and some of the comments thatt people say arent even close to being merit worthy. (i've looked throuhg som of the links)
Okay first of all it's a honor system that people nominate you. The Merit_Recognition page doesn't do all the work. There are key people that help out but mostly it's just your fellow gamers that help you get merits. I mean I don't agree with the merit example that you showed earlier but I know that good merit worthy comments are being trashed away because no one reads it or people are just to lazy to nominate you. I say that you should just keep it up and people will nominate you. You just have to keep at it!
Yes he is right the page does not give people merits for thier comments they just help speed the process.
Wait the one that got merited (not evan a word) was that all of it?
And every mod has ones they think are bad,okey and good! So some mod might like it, another would hate it, and like king said not all comments that are long get a merit! And mabey you don't describe the game to well, you probly put some deacent lines in, but the rest are probly about something other then the game. try the guide!
we already have a topic like this and it has been locked, but il explain.
next too the comment you see an arrow (vote up).
it isn't giving a merit it just gets the attention of moderators, they decide if the comment is good or bad.
once they think the comment is good they give you a merit (25AP).
for more information here is a link.
WOW! That's like a perfect comment!! If I woulda seen that I would've nominated you! See it's things like that, that people need to see and actually take action. People don't think for anyone else BUT themselves it's sick! That's an amazing comment!!
It is pretty good. But maybe they haven't got to it its pretty good.
well i wrote 6 merit whorth comments and all over 20 lines but i just have 2 merits
Thread is locked!