There should still be a Forum for clans.

Would those be exclusive forums, or could anyone just post in the clan forum without being part of a clan?

Either way, it seems like a waste of programming to me. I don't see why you can't just make your own offsite forum and use that. That to me makes more sense, because you can choose your own clan moderators and admins.

I think the whole role thing is too complicated for what it's worth.  It should just stay like a Facebook group or something.

I agree with this idea

It's easier to make a clan forum, than going through the trouble of making and paying a website. I'm not that good with computer programming.

I don't see why you can't just make your own offsite forum and use that. That to me makes more sense, because you can choose your own clan moderators and admins.

A chat service would probably prove to be more useful, since most user-made clans here don't seem to get that many members. Something like Xat, where the creator of the room can make people mods and stuff, and they don't have to follow AG rules while talking there.

If you read the first few pages they seem to have it all figured out. How clan leaders and members will work out, but I don't think they specified a place where they can communicate, other than the obvious profiles.

I think a subforum for clans would work like the newcomers section; the general idea is for newcomers to introduce themselves, but anyone can post there. The clan section would be like that, users creating threads specifically for their clan members, but I don't think they'd isolate people from posting.

It's easier to make a clan forum, than going through the trouble of making and paying a website. I'm not that good with computer programming.

It's incredibly easy to create forums and chat boxes these days. There are numerous forum and chat engines out there that allow you to create forums and chats free of cost and void of programming.

A chat service would probably prove to be more useful, since most user-made clans here don't seem to get that many members.

It would prove useful for a smaller group, but you'd have to rely on everyone to be online at the same time to have a real discussion. With a forum, a discussion could take place over a longer time span without worrying about whether or not people are going to miss it entirely by not being online at the right time.

Of course, it's not difficult to add a chatbox to a custom-made forum.

wanna join my clan first 5 are high ranks off the bat and i am not a spammer

With a forum, a discussion could take place over a longer time span without worrying about whether or not people are going to miss it entirely by not being online at the right time.

Then this sounds like the best idea. A subforum for clans, but they shouldn't exclude people from posting there if they're not in the clan.

wanna join my clan first 5 are high ranks off the bat and i am not a spammer

This isn't the place to recruit clan members.

i believe it will be a good site

i believe it will be a good site

From the time it's taking them to finish it, it better be more than just good! If it doesn't end up being worth the wait, they might as well just not change a thing and leave this site the way it is...

And that will give the admins time to finally fix all these BUGS once and for all... =P