ForumsPopular Media"OvC" Song Battle # 16 : Immigrant Song (Page 19)

199 111753
MrDayCee
offline
MrDayCee
13,547 posts
King

This thread is an idea I had for a long time now and it seems like a radio DJ had it too! Since I heard it being held on the radio, I thought it was finally time to introduce it to the music loving users of ArmorGames! Presenting...

http://farm8.staticflickr.com/7212/7261671524_e00db72481_z_d.jpg

Throughout the history of music, artists have recorded numerous songs for people to enjoy, but sometimes... another artist thinks he/she/they can perform that same song better or think of a different approach/interpretation of it! This can produce a completely different song, sometimes with a big improvement, sometimes it's a complete failure and every now and then... a true (new) gem is made!! =)

This battle thread is all about comparing those songs and the rules of engagement are pretty simple... I post a battle between two songs, one is the original version and one is the cover version. You can vote (once only per battle) for either of the two artists featured in battle, giving them 1 point for your preferenced vote! And an elaborated reasoning is of course required for your vote to be counted in the score roundup, we don't want this thread to be flooded with spam posts after all...

Note this : on several occasions some songs have actually been covered by more than one single artist, therefor battles with more than two artists featured may occur sometimes; the rules will always stay the same though! To clarify once more...

Short list of rules :

1) I will post a new battle ('every week';
2) Only one vote per user, per battle;
3) A reasoning is required to count your vote.


Plain, simple and fun! =)

And if you feel that a certain song needs to be presented in a battle in this thread, please post the battle suggestions on my profile, do NOT post them in this thread as this will only become confusing about which battle is currently featured!

Hope you will like this idea and participate in it! =)

  • 199 Replies
kegaumongo
offline
kegaumongo
2,161 posts
Regent

Well, I didn't know this song at all and, also, half of the artists of this round. Besides, I have to say that this song really gives me bad vibrations. It's definitely not a song I can listen to many times.

I think Judas Priest's cover is okay, though I'm not a fan of the singer's voice because I don't think it fits this kind of song quite well. However, it sounds like any other rock song (no offence). There is nothing, in my opinion, that makes this cover stand out from the rest. It's just okay.

What I like the most about Therion's cover is the guitar sound. It is pretty good. They made this song much more upbeat, so they somehow erased the strange atmosphere that the original song has.

Arthur Brown did a good job with this song, as his cover is quite peculiar. I really enjoy the musical part, especially the saxophone (which I never expected to see in a song like this, to be honest). Though the way he sings may be a bit theatrical, I think his voice really suits this song.

And finally the original, which has an incredibly spooky vibe like none of the above. It scares me for some reason. Maybe because of the guitars or the way it is sung or both, I don't know. So that's the main reason why I'm voting for it, because it's been quite a long time since a song has made me felt this way. Maybe this isn't the most solid reasoning, but it's the only one I have.

So my vote goes to Fleetwood Mac.

Ernie15
offline
Ernie15
13,428 posts
Herald

I'm going to be honest, I didn't really care much for any version of the song.

The original version by Fleetwood Mac was a bit too psychedelic for my tastes. It seemed as if it focused too much on the weird psychedelic vibes it was trying to put out there rather than the music itself, which reflected upon the poor quality of the song. Arthur Brown's version was a tribute to Peter Green, so of course it sounded similar to the original version.

If I had to choose one, I would have to go with Judas Priest because they gave it a more upbeat, solid feel that the original version lacked. It actually sounded somewhat professional and not just like a bunch of guys in their garage jamming almost indefinitely. Therion, who based their cover off the Priest version rather than the original, also did a fine job, but the voice was a bit over the top and it sounded like they were just trying to dramatize the Priest version. Still would be my second choice, if I had to pick one.

ilberic
offline
ilberic
858 posts
Scribe

Ok, since we're on the second page for this battle, I'll add a tally so that others can see the competitors. For those that need samples to rate the songs, they can be found on page 18 of this thread.

So the totals for this battle so far:

Judas Priest - 2
Fleetwood Mac - 1
Arthur Brown - 0
Therion - 0

Bring in the votes people!

partydevil
offline
partydevil
5,168 posts
Bard

oke, let's see what this round brings.
ive never heard of the band or the song in general. so i'll gonna type while listening. this might end up really wierd. but i'm gonna try it.

Peter Green's Fleetwood Mac


it has a nice and simple intro and a great (old) sound.
the voice is also great. a little bit of the same tho. if this is how he sings all his songs then i think i can't listen to more then just a few tracks befor wanting to change it.

this sounds like a great song to put on while cruising on a empty highway in the middle of the night. (added to fav. list ^^)

Judas Priest

they brought allot more rock to the song and the intro seems less of the same. the old sound has been changed to better quality. wich is both a + and a - .
the voice sounds good whit the rest of the song and the added guitar solo's gives it a extra taste.
it's less cruising material then the original but still good enough to put on once in a while.

Arthur Brown

au! he ***** the intro badly. didn't saw that comming.
the instruments do there best to make it sound good and sometimes they do so. but then this guy is singing and the instruments almost stop? =S
why is that? it this voice that i really dont like. he try's to hard it seems.
where is the trashcan?

Therion

a cover-cover. =S oke let's try it.

the intro seems gone from the original. they start whit the 2nd part.
but the guitars sound good aswell as the voice. nothing special really. there are hundreds of these kinda songs out there. the guitar solo however is much better then those of the others. it's a nice song to play once in a while for sure. but not really more then that.

=================================
i find it kinda hard to compare Therion whit the original. there barely is anything left of the song. (except the lyrics maybe, i didn't listen to that)
so for those 2 i have to just decide what kind of song do i like more. and normally it would be the cover-cover. but this original is such a great cruising song that i favor it more then the metal.

Arthur Brown go's bottom line but i think you all would have guessed that already. =P

judas priest and therion was better to compare whit eatch other. i find that singing in general comes much more naturally for judas priest. and he kept the original song more in tact then therion did. therefor he go's above therion.

now only the last is left and that judas priest and Fleetwood Mac.also.
normally i would choose for the metal/rock. but not today.

1. Fleetwood Mac
2. Judas Priest
3. Therion
40. Arthur Brown
partydevil
offline
partydevil
5,168 posts
Bard

now only the last is left and that judas priest and Fleetwood Mac.also.
normally i would choose for the metal/rock. but not today.


now only the last is left and that judas priest and Fleetwood Mac
it's also like whit therion.
normally i would choose for the metal/rock. but not today.
xXxDAPRO89xXx
offline
xXxDAPRO89xXx
6,794 posts
Count

DayCee or ilberic is one of you guys gonna bring this thread back? Or is it long lost

MrDayCee
offline
MrDayCee
13,547 posts
King

I was cleaning up a bit and what did I find hidden somewhere in a dark corner...?!

The "OvC" thread!! Time to dust it off and present a new battle to the music loving users of the Armor Games Community!! =)

First to tie up a loose end... the score for the last battle held:
_____________________________________________________________________________

Final Score Battle # 15: Green Manalishi (With the Two Prong Crown)
_____________________________________________________________________________

2 - Fleetwood Mac (Original) - Tied for First!
2 - Judas Priest (Cover) - Tied for First!

0 - Therion (Cover)
0 - Arthur Brown (Cover)
_____________________________________________________________________________

...

Now, on with the next battle -yes it has been a while- in this voting competition! Presenting:

Battle # 16 : Immigrant Song

http://farm4.staticflickr.com/3675/12657275404_a458aa1ff7_o_d.png

And of course, some examples to help you choose your winner in this battle :

~ Led Zeppelin (Original - 1970 - LIVE)
~ Adagio (Cover - 2001 - Instrumental)
~ Tomoyashu Hotei (Cover - 2004)
~ Demons & Wizards (Cover - 2005)
~ Ann Wilson (Cover - 2007)
~ Stryper (Cover - 2011)


There were more covers out there, a whole lot of them, even from Nirvana and Queen! But those two were of such poor quality, I decided to leave them out of this round... I bet you would come to alter your thoughts about these bands if you were to hear such bad recordings...

Allright! On with the show!! Y'all ready?!

On we sweep with, with threshing oar...
Our only goal will be to ... RING THAT BELL!!


http://farm8.staticflickr.com/7079/7261876542_c96da7bf7d_d.jpg

VOTE!!!

Ernie15
offline
Ernie15
13,428 posts
Herald

I was going to vote for the original, until I heard Ann Wilson's cover. Truly beautiful. It had that Magic Man-esque haunting feel to it, and Magic Man being one of my favorite songs of any era, it would have been hard not to vote for that voice.

As far as honorable mentions that have not yet been mentioned go, this song isn't quite a cover, but I felt it was still relevant to the battle.

Also, listening to all these covers made me realize Led Zeppelin totally ripped off the Get Smart theme.

UnleashedUponMankind
online
UnleashedUponMankind
11,622 posts
Viceroy

The original, for sure.
Accidently i knew two of the cover versions and they never reach the original...
I know the other three performers/bands, and this make one thing clear for me: there is no need to hear their versions...^^

MrDayCee
offline
MrDayCee
13,547 posts
King

@Ernie15 Man... that was a deception... (oO) ...I really thought they made an original song there! LOL ^^

Ah, well... I'm glad you didn't link the Queen version as a cover that deserves an honorable mentioning! That improvised piece of crappery-crap-crap-crap was not worthy of Queen's massive legacy, let alone being compared to an immense icon the legendary band Led Zeppelin is... *facepalms* =/

Right... the show must go on! (bad pun to be ignored) First score count for:
____________________________________

Battle # 16 Immigrant Song :
____________________________________

1 - Led Zeppelin (Original)
1 - Ann Wilson (Cover)
0 - Adagio (Cover)
0 - Tomoyashu Hotei (Cover)
0 - Demons & Wizards (Cover)
0 - Stryper (Cover)
____________________________________

More votes wanted! =)

xXxDAPRO89xXx
offline
xXxDAPRO89xXx
6,794 posts
Count

Led Zeppelin for sure. I didn't really bother to listen to all of the covers but I love the original

gh0sts
offline
gh0sts
877 posts
Farmer

The original is still the best. Ann Wilson did a nice job, but it doesn't compare to Zep's version.

CherryCoke360
offline
CherryCoke360
410 posts
Peasant

None of these covers are anywhere near as good as the original and half of them sound exactly the same. definitely the original, cant be beat

DrElmer
offline
DrElmer
553 posts
Farmer

The covers start out decent, but they all turn into tuneless metal songs somewhere down the line. The one that really caught me with my pants around my ankles was Ann Wilson. She did a remarkable job imitating Robert Plant's voice, but even in that case the beginning was the only good part.

Led Zeppelin made the song short and sweet, and no metal singer is going to be able to imitate Robert's infamous screech at the beginning of the song.

GandalftheGrey666
offline
GandalftheGrey666
1,876 posts
Shepherd

The original is the best. Even though I haven't heard the covers, they sure can't match the original song.

no metal singer is going to be able to imitate Robert's infamous screech at the beginning of the song.


^This
Showing 181-195 of 199