Wouldn't you find this to be better? It's a stickied thread with this subject and has a lot of games mentioned in there, so you'll have plenty to play.
That's a difficult thing to answer as I'm sure most people don't have a "favorite game of all time". There are several games that I love, across many different genres. However, if you're just looking for some games to play that other people like, I can name a few.
-Final Fantasy 8 -Skyrim -Super Metroid -Animal Crossing
