ForumsThe TavernDr. Pepper vs. Mr. Pibb

10 4333
eyetwitch
offline
eyetwitch
737 posts
Shepherd

Starscream's powerade v. gatorade topic got me thinkin about this. Atleast to question what ya'll think.

1. What is the Difference?
2. Which Do you prefer?


I will answer as well.
I am really curious to see what people say since most people can't tell a difference...but as a DP/MP addict i can tell a difference. Dr. Pepper i think, is more carbonated and less sweet. While Mr. Pibb is less carbonated and more sweet, and as such i like Mr. Pibb more although i will and do drink them both. (DP more because its more common) as a side note i also like them from a fountain more than bottled.

  • 10 Replies
parkermb68
offline
parkermb68
323 posts
Nomad

DP all the way!(Dr.Pepper)

Carlie
offline
Carlie
6,843 posts
Blacksmith

No question, Dr. Pepper all the way!

Dr. Pepper from a fountain is better than Dr. Pepper from a can, which is better than any sort of Mr. Pibb. If you will:
Fountain DP > Can DP > Mr. Pibb

JustLacrosse21
offline
JustLacrosse21
248 posts
Nomad

DP ALL THE WAY!!!!.....i love that stuff!

plokkey
offline
plokkey
4,572 posts
Jester

Isn't mr pibb a rip off od DP?

xfirealchemistx
offline
xfirealchemistx
370 posts
Nomad

I prefer Dr. Pepper out of Mr. Pibb vs. Dr. Pepper. Really my drink of choice is a good ole pepsi. Besides mr. Pibb is a cheap generic brand of Dr. Pepper.

turret
offline
turret
1,628 posts
Shepherd

DP cause i love it and i had some reacently.... it was tasty

boalx
offline
boalx
74 posts
Nomad

dp its my 2nd favorite drink and it is the more common

BlazeLax38
offline
BlazeLax38
63 posts
Nomad

I like them both but mr. pibb is too fizzy. just like diet coke and pepsi. pepsi is good. coke is too fizzy.

soccer_mylife
offline
soccer_mylife
388 posts
Nomad

mr pibb i like the fiz and it has better flavor

Graham
offline
Graham
8,052 posts
Nomad

last time i can remember i think mr pibb tasted like rootbeer and dp combined

DP wins all

Showing 1-10 of 10