Hmmm, how about both? Something stupid but funny like Hot Fuzz, Shawn of the Dead, Scary Movie(only one of them, can't remember which, but the rest are stupid).
Either way, Comedy, Gore, or both, I'm happy, but usually Gory movies are cheap and end up making me laugh at how cheesy they are, I can't get through something like Resident Evil or Saw 1-4(or 3, how many are there?) without having to leave cause they're so stupid. Comedy movies, like Galaxy Quest, Evolution, Space Balls, stuff like that is the best, I would have to side with Comedy because either way I'm getting a good laugh, might as well be a genre where I won't be the only one laughing(as horror I would lol). So yeah, my breakdown =D
That is a really hard choice, and great forum idea I might add. But, I'm probably going to have to go with tie. Only because it's a really hard decision.