Halo 3 is my favorite due to how long it takes to die. Others dislike this but I think it makes it more challenging. I give credit to Call of duty 4 because dying from a couple shots is more realistic. Guitar hero 3 is a great game even tho rock band is superior. I really hope Guitar hero world tour has a character creation for Wii, little disappointed they left that out for rockband Wii. I've never played soulcaliber 4 but I think darth vader and yoda is a pretty cool touch to it.
now cod4 and halo3 are both FPS games.. but where does soulcalibur4 and GH3 come in? if u compare games u should compare it so that all games have 1 thing in common , eg : halo 3 , cod4 , battlefield bad comapny , gears of war , resistance .. etc
i think halo 3 has more replay value online but COD4 is a lot more smoother and dosent glitch as much GH3 is an allright game but not better than halo 3 or COD4 soul calibar 4 has a lot of characters and the graphics are great but it gets boring pretty quickly