Forums → Art, Music, and Writing → Art Skills Contest

6854	5702322

offline

Carlie

6,823 posts

Blacksmith

Posted September 11, '08 8:55pm UTC

Hello and welcome!

This is a spin-off of the original GFX Art Battle, but with some updated rules and changes. Please make sure to read the rules before entering, since they have been modified. Good luck, we look forward to seeing some creative artistic entries!

Competition Rules
1. Must be hand drawn, either on paper or in a program. It can then be manipulated in an graphics program. But unoriginal artwork cannot be used as the main focus. Copyrighted images cannot be used. All pieces containing copyrighted images will be disqualified.
2. Submissions must follow the current theme that has been chosen by a moderator for that week. If you submit more than one piece, please clarify which one you would like to be judged.
3. If your image is larger than 600 pixels wide, please provide a link to the image instead of posting it in the forum. Otherwise, the image will be cut off.
4. Artists cannot win in subsequent weeks. You can still submit, but if you won the week before, you cannot get first place again the next week.
5. After the deadline, a moderator will pick the winner, and they will be awarded a 25 AP award.

Hello and welcome! \r\n\r\nThis is a spin-off of the original [url=http://armorgames.com/community/thread/1185080/gfx-art-battles]GFX Art Battle[/url], but with some updated rules and changes. Please make sure to read the rules before entering, since they have been modified. Good luck, we look forward to seeing some creative artistic entries! \r\n\r\n[b]Competition Rules[/b]\r\n1. [i]Must be hand drawn, either on paper or in a program. It can then be manipulated in an graphics program. But unoriginal artwork cannot be used as the main focus. Copyrighted images cannot be used. All pieces containing copyrighted images will be disqualified.[/i]\r\n2. [i]Submissions must follow the current theme that has been chosen by a moderator for that week. If you submit more than one piece, please clarify which one you would like to be judged.[/i]\r\n3. [i]If your image is larger than 600 pixels wide, please provide a link to the image instead of posting it in the forum. Otherwise, the image will be cut off.[/i]\r\n4. [i]Artists cannot win in subsequent weeks. You can still submit, but if you won the week before, you cannot get first place again the next week.[/i]\r\n5. [i]After the deadline, a moderator will pick the winner, and they will be awarded a 25 AP award.[/i]

6,854 Replies

offline

Cenere

13,657 posts

Jester

Posted September 15, '09 12:47pm UTC

Lessee...
Bronze: You cannot win in two rounds in a row. You can, on the other hand participate in all the rounds you like.
And I usually participate in all the rounds, even though I judge said round. Both for the challenge and for having a feeling how the theme is. Wouldn't give you a theme I wouldn't draw myself.
Besides the fact that I have taken a break from entering due to exams and summer, that is how I do.

The judging "Issue": I see Ernie seem to have a problem with only having one judge, even though he was too a lone judge.
Yet, I have only had complains on one judging, the Poltergeist one, and that was just because I chose to stick to the theme. (And Strop scolding me for being rude, but I doubt that count as judging as much as way of acting)
Besides that, only complains have been on the theme, and I trust the users will tell at least me, if they find it unfair, as long as I give my reasons for said choice.

If the reason for three mods was to give scores and that way find the winner, I have seen that it does not work. Zophia and I are debating our choices if we disagree with each other, and if we agree, there probably is a reason, which is why we do not give scores, but actual explanations.
If your problems is that one person (Zophia has not left the judging, she has just stated she alone might not be the best option) would not be fair, then yes, you might want to find some judges you actually trust will be fair, instead of someone like me.

As for the horse, there are fault. Don't know the commercial and... Ended up having a major migraine, so I don't think it went too well.

Lessee...\r\nBronze: You cannot win in two rounds in a row. You can, on the other hand participate in all the rounds you like.\r\nAnd I usually participate in all the rounds, even though I judge said round. Both for the challenge and for having a feeling how the theme is. Wouldn't give you a theme I wouldn't draw myself.\r\nBesides the fact that I have taken a break from entering due to exams and summer, that is how I do.\r\n\r\nThe judging "Issue": I see Ernie seem to have a problem with only having one judge, even though he was too a lone judge.\r\nYet, I have only had complains on one judging, the Poltergeist one, and that was just because I chose to stick to the theme. (And Strop scolding me for being rude, but I doubt that count as judging as much as way of acting)\r\nBesides that, only complains have been on the theme, and I trust the users will tell at least me, if they find it unfair, as long as I give my reasons for said choice.\r\n\r\nIf the reason for three mods was to give scores and that way find the winner, I have seen that it does not work. Zophia and I are debating our choices if we disagree with each other, and if we agree, there probably is a reason, which is why we do not give scores, but actual explanations.\r\nIf your problems is that one person (Zophia has not left the judging, she has just stated she alone might not be the best option) would not be fair, then yes, you might want to find some judges you actually trust will be fair, instead of someone like me.\r\n\r\nAs for the horse, there are fault. Don't know the commercial and... Ended up having a major migraine, so I don't think it went too well.

offline

Zophia

9,434 posts

Scribe

Posted September 15, '09 12:48pm UTC

Man, you guys really got riled up, eh?
General agreeing with Cen here.

Seriously, though, if you think there should be a change of judging methods because the current judges aren't fair, that's.. That honestly surprises me. o.o One thing is that a specific judge might like a certain kind of entry better (that's been obvious at least since Strop was judge), another is if you think such preferences break the competition. I only noticed Ernie complaining, though.. Is it an actual issue for more people? Speak your minds!

Anyway.

Rushed judging of two rounds at once go!

First, the Cute theme

Champion's Exhibit
crimsonblade55

O.o.. .. .. .. .. ..
Remind me not to take those drugs.

First place
Cenere

Only entry that made me go Aww! out loud. It's too frigid adorable, and I'm too impressed that you did that in the GIMP.

Second place
Thoad

1) Those little guys are adorable.
2) The pearly eyes.
3) You got the nightmarish considerations in. :3

Third place
RaptorExx

Frog^^ And a clip-on-skin tie. :P Looks pretty cute to me~ Nice smooth coloring and lines, btw, what did you draw it in?

The rest of the entries:

Perslos

Four lines, a floodfill and copy/paste? That's, uh, it doesn't look like it took a whole lot of time or effort, not even on the getting an idea side. More happy than cute, methinks.

Zega

The yellow one is absolutely adorably. It's something with those pearly eyes, they're just instant cuteness, sometimes even if you slap them onto a ferocious monster. The other shapes are pretty cute too~ And you're making good progress with your shading skills.

GuitarHeroFtw

Duckling Pacmans?~ Happycute~ You could easily have done more to your entry, though, it's very simplistic as it is (that's not necessarily a bad thing, I just think it would have been more interesting with, dunno, maybe a simple line as a background?).

Pixie214

Bambiraptor? O.o Sorta cute name, yes~ Your drawing itself would have been a lot more cute if you'd given it a larger pupil, though. As it is, the critter kinda looks either retarded or scared. Bonus cookie for oddly creative take on the theme, though~

goumas13

That's actually quite well drawn (although you might wanna fix the levels, I think the scanner ate the colours). Are children cute?

superpickle

(Image links to the - disturbing version.)
DEMON CAT WITH HEARTSES. > > It's cute. In the horror movie kind of cute way. Which is cool, but disturbing~

Bronze

It's a pretty cool drawing, very good shading, good proportions for a baby too, though the face is a bit skewed. However, I don't consider it cute. Happy, sure, charming, yeah.. Cute, not so much? Might be because it's a baby and I find those kinda scary and stuff..

jdoggparty

The less gay version!~
It is sorta cute, it is~ I think maybe you should have used a slightly thicker line for their lips?

Owen135731

Sad triangle? :< The shape thing done again~ Cute, but not cute enough to win.

zlith

Personally, I think it's more funny than it's cute. But it is pretty funny~

Oh, and at this point I've gotten through the pages to what Apocalypse wanted to be his entry. But entries have to be drawn for this competition, and I clearly remember that specific stick figure drawing being made for a specific something else. Possibly why it's not really cute anyway. > >

kingryan

Oh my, it blinks/flaps! You're not supposed to do that outside the animation competition, KR. :P (Also, as Bronze said, it would look better if they didn't do the blink/flap at the exact same time.) Cute, though.

parrot657

Glad you remembered to give brush credit~ Credit for Swablu is of course to Nintendo and all that... But yes, it is a cute pokemon^^
What program did you make it in? Generally that kind of squares aren't supposed to be saved to the finished image, so just wondering how you ended up with that.

Okay.
That was the first round.
Next round coming up in a bit.

Man, you guys really got riled up, eh?\r\nGeneral agreeing with Cen here.\r\n\r\nSeriously, though, if you think there should be a change of judging methods because the current judges aren't fair, that's.. That honestly surprises me. o.o One thing is that a specific judge might like a certain kind of entry better (that's been obvious at least since Strop was judge), another is if you think such preferences break the competition. I only noticed Ernie complaining, though.. Is it an actual issue for more people? Speak your minds!\r\n\r\nAnyway.\r\n\r\nRushed judging of two rounds at once go!\r\n\r\n[b]First, the Cute theme[/b]\r\n\r\nChampion's Exhibit\r\ncrimsonblade55\r\n[img]http://i530.photobucket.com/albums/dd349/crimsonblade55/Cute.png[/img]\r\nO.o.. .. .. .. .. ..\r\nRemind me not to take those drugs.\r\n\r\nFirst place\r\nCenere\r\n[img]http://i428.photobucket.com/albums/qq1/Cerene_Cerine/cute.jpg[/img]\r\nOnly entry that made me go Aww! out loud. It's too frigid adorable, and I'm too impressed that you did that in the GIMP.\r\n\r\nSecond place\r\nThoad\r\n\r\n[img]http://fc09.deviantart.com/fs28/i/2009/244/4/b/ASC_____Cute___by_Thoadthetoad.jpg[/img]\r\n\r\n1) Those little guys are adorable.\r\n2) The pearly eyes.\r\n3) You got the nightmarish considerations in. :3\r\n\r\nThird place\r\nRaptorExx\r\n[img]http://fc00.deviantart.com/fs30/f/2009/246/6/4/Theme__Cute_by_SpyroSteak.png[/img]\r\nFrog^^ And a clip-on-skin tie. :P  Looks pretty cute to me~ Nice smooth coloring and lines, btw, what did you draw it in?\r\n\r\nThe rest of the entries:\r\n\r\nPerslos\r\n[img]http://i730.photobucket.com/albums/ww305/Perslos/Gagcopy2.png[/img]\r\nFour lines, a floodfill and copy/paste? That's, uh, it doesn't look like it took a whole lot of time or effort, not even on the getting an idea side. More happy than cute, methinks.\r\n\r\nZega\r\n[img]http://i385.photobucket.com/albums/oo296/Zega96/CuteWalkX.png[/img]\r\nThe yellow one is absolutely adorably. It's something with those pearly eyes, they're just instant cuteness, sometimes even if you slap them onto a ferocious monster. The other shapes are pretty cute too~ And you're making good progress with your shading skills.\r\n\r\nGuitarHeroFtw\r\n\r\n[img]http://img196.imageshack.us/img196/5899/fdeghbnjmkl.jpg[/img]\r\n\r\nDuckling Pacmans?~ Happycute~ You could easily have done more to your entry, though, it's very simplistic as it is (that's not necessarily a bad thing, I just think it would have been more interesting with, dunno, maybe a simple line as a background?).\r\n \r\nPixie214\r\n\r\n[img]http://img26.imageshack.us/img26/4829/bambiraptor.jpg[/img]\r\n\r\nBambiraptor? O.o Sorta cute name, yes~ Your drawing itself would have been a lot more cute if you'd given it a larger pupil, though. As it is, the critter kinda looks either retarded or scared. Bonus cookie for oddly creative take on the theme, though~\r\n\r\ngoumas13\r\n[img]http://i693.photobucket.com/albums/vv296/goumas13/paidaki.jpg[/img]\r\nThat's actually quite well drawn (although you might wanna fix the levels, I think the scanner ate the colours). Are children cute?\r\n\r\nsuperpickle\r\n[url=http://i542.photobucket.com/albums/gg414/super-pickle/sicklycat-1.jpg][img]http://i542.photobucket.com/albums/gg414/super-pickle/sicklycat.jpg[/img][/url]\r\n(Image links to the - disturbing version.)\r\nDEMON CAT WITH HEARTSES.  > > It's cute. In the horror movie kind of cute way. Which is cool, but disturbing~\r\n\r\nBronze\r\n[img]http://i584.photobucket.com/albums/ss282/BronzeCAE09/Baby.jpg[/img]\r\nIt's a pretty cool drawing, very good shading, good proportions for a baby too, though the face is a bit skewed. However, I don't consider it cute. Happy, sure, charming, yeah.. Cute, not so much? Might be because it's a baby and I find those kinda scary and stuff..\r\n\r\njdoggparty\r\n[img]http://i31.tinypic.com/33n91e9.png[/img]\r\nThe less gay version!~\r\nIt is sorta cute, it is~ I think maybe you should have used a slightly thicker line for their lips?\r\n\r\nOwen135731\r\n[img]http://i449.photobucket.com/albums/qq211/Owen135731/Cute.jpg[/img]\r\nSad triangle? :< The shape thing done again~ Cute, but not cute enough to win.\r\n\r\nzlith\r\n[img]http://i846.photobucket.com/albums/ab22/zlith/cute.png[/img]\r\nPersonally, I think it's more funny than it's cute. But it is pretty funny~\r\n\r\nOh, and at this point I've gotten through the pages to what Apocalypse wanted to be his entry. But entries have to be drawn for this competition, and I clearly remember that specific stick figure drawing being made for a specific something else. Possibly why it's not really cute anyway. > >\r\n\r\nkingryan\r\n[img]http://i296.photobucket.com/albums/mm193/kingryanv/cute.gif[/img]\r\nOh my, it blinks/flaps! You're not supposed to do that outside the animation competition, KR. :P (Also, as Bronze said, it would look better if they didn't do the blink/flap at the exact same time.) Cute, though.\r\n\r\nparrot657\r\n[img]http://img228.imageshack.us/img228/8000/swablu.gif[/img]\r\nGlad you remembered to give brush credit~ Credit for Swablu is of course to Nintendo and all that... But yes, it is a cute pokemon^^\r\nWhat program did you make it in? Generally that kind of squares aren't supposed to be saved to the finished image, so just wondering how you ended up with that.\r\n\r\nOkay.\r\nThat was the first round.\r\nNext round coming up in a bit.

offline

Bronze

2,417 posts

Shepherd

Posted September 15, '09 2:18pm UTC

Next round coming up in a bit.

I hope you mean in a few days because...well I'm trying to make the best drawing of my life.

*sigh* *grumbblesaboutzophnotfindingbabiescute*

offline

Zophia

9,434 posts

Scribe

Posted September 15, '09 2:22pm UTC

Well, human babies...

On a rare occasion they can be absolutely adorable. Yours just... Well, the face... It's just kinda scary...

Also, the concept of children associated with war materials doesn't strike me as cute.

The quality of your drawing, however, is good.

I hope you mean in a few days because...well I'm trying to make the best drawing of my life.

I did actually mean later today, and I also said a few days ago that I would end the rounds Monday or Tuesday.

offline

parrot657

896 posts

Nomad

Posted September 15, '09 2:23pm UTC

*sigh* *grumbblesaboutzophnotfindingbabiescute*

I don't think babies are cute...

Glad you remembered to give brush credit~ Credit for Swablu is of course to Nintendo and all that... But yes, it is a cute pokemon^^
What program did you make it in? Generally that kind of squares aren't supposed to be saved to the finished image, so just wondering how you ended up with that.

What about the drawing? lol.
I hopes I get a place on the next judging .

offline

Zophia

9,434 posts

Scribe

Posted September 15, '09 2:25pm UTC

What about the drawing? lol.

Oh, sorry, didn't realize I kinda forgot to say anything specific about it x_x

It's a decent rendition of a classical Swablu pose, and the background colour theme suits it. Didn't need as much background as it has, though, could have been cropped smaller~

offline

parrot657

896 posts

Nomad

Posted September 15, '09 2:55pm UTC

thanks, and when's equines judging? I used gimp for the swablu by the way, I have no idea why it saved the stupid squares

offline

Hectichermit

1,828 posts

Bard

Posted September 15, '09 4:11pm UTC

lol I'm glad I didn't come across the cute theme, I am horrible at the cute stuff...hmm Zophia doo you like Anime? Pearl/large eyes is a usual style

offline

Bronze

2,417 posts

Shepherd

Posted September 15, '09 4:15pm UTC

Well we have 4 entries now since we can't count Cen's.

I have to color mine right now.

Hope we get more entries, anybody know what the lowest amount of entries for a single theme is?

offline

Hectichermit

1,828 posts

Bard

Posted September 15, '09 4:43pm UTC

I wonder what the next theme will be...o well might as well make something to kill time

offline

Cenere

13,657 posts

Jester

Posted September 15, '09 4:50pm UTC

Zophia doo you like Anime? Pearl/large eyes is a usual style

http://shutterbug8288.deviantart.com/art/A-mouse-33087681

OMG NATURE HAS ANIME!

offline

Pixie214

5,838 posts

Peasant

Posted September 15, '09 4:57pm UTC

Bonus cookie for oddly creative take on the theme, though~

I saw the name and just though "aaawwhh :3" lol Anyway Yay!! for judging... *looks at new theme* Runs..

offline

Zophia

9,434 posts

Scribe

Posted September 15, '09 4:59pm UTC

thanks, and when's equines judging?

It was supposed to be now, but I got distracted. And Bronze seemed to want a smidgen more time. I'm guessing tomorrow.

lol I'm glad I didn't come across the cute theme, I am horrible at the cute stuff...hmm Zophia doo you like Anime? Pearl/large eyes is a usual style

I don't usually think of pearly eyes as an anime trait (Cenere pointed out a good reason why). But I do like some anime/manga. Not the horribly large eyes, though.

Hope we get more entries, anybody know what the lowest amount of entries for a single theme is?

Three. If there's less than three, there will be no merit and no judging, because picking one out of two is - mean. > >

offline

Bronze

2,417 posts

Shepherd

Posted September 15, '09 5:36pm UTC

And Bronze seemed to want a smidgen more time. I'm guessing tomorrow.

Yes and thankyou. It will be worth the wait I promise. I don't have time to do everything I wanted (I was even going to do a background :O)

*sigh* coloring is tedious work, layer after layer.

offline

Zega

6,921 posts

Peasant

Posted September 15, '09 5:36pm UTC

Ruggerbogger, thankz for finally judging!

I can't draw horses. xP

Showing 5926-5940 of 6854

Categories

Quests

Community

Forums → Art, Music, and Writing → Art Skills Contest