Forums → Games → GTA 4 or Saints Row 2? Why?

I'll go with GT4 because it made more than 1 million dollars in the first week, that's amazing isn't it?

it might be more than that

GTA because saints row is just a ripoff. it also isnt as smooth, the physics are kinda off, and everything looks so small in saints row as opposed to GTA where everything is huge.

good reasons but dont forget the graphics and the story

saints row has a shitty story and its very unrealistic

saints row is better for stunt machinimas though

i love saints row 2 its really fun but gta 4 is way better

I see that Saints Row is getting called out for being a ripoff, but how many of you have actually played it? I have not, but I've heard that it has some really fun stuff in it that GTA 4 does not. Also, GTA left out a lot of things that should be standard (like stats?) with GTA games now. However, the story and development to GTA 4 is spectacular.

zenkin your right the stats system is left out, but i think many players enjoy that. theres also a lot more collectibles. GTA san andreas had stats but the replay value was kinda low. i guess they learned something

Saints Row 2, Why? Respect, Gangs, Stores, Weapons, and have you actually played it and thought about it?