ForumsGamesTurn based strategy versus Real time strategy

18 4234
zzzman201
offline
zzzman201
78 posts
Nomad

what is better? tbs games like civilization or rts games like starcraft? I love civilization and starcraft but, I have to pick tbs games because civilization has alot more depth to it.

  • 18 Replies
Talo
offline
Talo
945 posts
Nomad

I like both for different reasons. I play Sins of a Solar Empire as one of the best RTS, and I like Turn based like Valkaria, Disgaea, Shining Force.

llamaeatataco
offline
llamaeatataco
164 posts
Nomad

Hey! you're forgetting Fire Emblem! it is, in my opinion the best tbs game series. ever. It is way more popular in Japan (mainly because the first half of the series is only available over there). I got the game and every firend that I lent it to has liked it.

but, on to the question: rts or tbs? I actually prefer either rts's that you can pause and issue orders(basically all in existance) or just tbs's.

Drace
offline
Drace
3,880 posts
Nomad

Real time, duh.

Talo
offline
Talo
945 posts
Nomad

Was the "duh" just you druling on yourself from being stupid? or do you really think that TBGs are never as great as RTSs

PsychoIncarnate
offline
PsychoIncarnate
1,037 posts
Nomad

Turn based strategies have flaws such as one side always going first, which makes them so their perfect balance is actually giving one side an advantage.


I prefer real time.


Besides, in video games, is there actually a good turn based strategy anyway? ...I think not

zzzman201
offline
zzzman201
78 posts
Nomad

civilization revolution is awesome so....i think yes

dragonball05
offline
dragonball05
1,717 posts
Shepherd

Ya like llama said, Fire Emblem is probably the greatest turn based game there is. Sure there's the flaw that one side always goes first, but all games have some kind of flaw if you think about it hard enough. At least that's my opinion so I prefer turn based games.

Silver333
offline
Silver333
208 posts
Nomad

Hm... Tough choice. Personally, I prefer (The Air!) Turn based Strategy games, such as Fire Emblem. But, there are some great rts games out there. My personal favorite is Plastic Army Men RTS. It's fun as well.

Caveman_
offline
Caveman_
22 posts
Nomad

Real time strategy is best, turn based is just booooooooooring.

zachattacksox
offline
zachattacksox
279 posts
Nomad

i like turn based better

zachattacksox
offline
zachattacksox
279 posts
Nomad

physcoincarnate is right turn based is good for flash but for video games not really

LiL_GaNgSta_BlAzE
offline
LiL_GaNgSta_BlAzE
2,269 posts
Jester

physcoincarnate is right turn based is good for flash but for video games not really


I agree, I mean can you imagine playing Tom Clancy's EndWar with turns?
cool_b_63
offline
cool_b_63
32 posts
Nomad

RTS.
RTS.
RTS.
Turn based gives you more time to think about your strategy, but real time is the best. It tests your skills better.
Nothing like being ambushed from behind by Zerglings in the middle of a battle.

knight_34
offline
knight_34
13,817 posts
Farmer

RTS.
RTS.
RTS.
Turn based gives you more time to think about your strategy, but real time is the best. It tests your skills better.
Nothing like being ambushed from behind by Zerglings in the middle of a battle.


Also agree.. RTS is suitable for more games then TBS.
shadedclan
offline
shadedclan
405 posts
Peasant

I think RTS if it would mean both of you were moving at the same time. I would personally like the TBS of Final Fantasy so in TBS this is the perfect choice.

Showing 1-15 of 18