ForumsGamesRPG vs FPS

45 9115
minno
offline
minno
93 posts
Peasant

Role playing game vs. first person shooter, in case you aren't quite geeky enough. Which one do you think is better? I personally like RPGs more, but I want to hear other peoples' opinions.

  • 45 Replies
sense
offline
sense
1,036 posts
Nomad

I love both of them... 10/10 each!

Draconigena
offline
Draconigena
102 posts
Nomad

It realy depends on the game and what a feel liek playing at the time. I spent a long time playing only RPG and RTS games and im a bit tired of them, so currently FPS.

Talo
offline
Talo
945 posts
Nomad

most RPGs have FPS aspects now. Just look at Fallout 3

skillzkillz
offline
skillzkillz
161 posts
Nomad

i love both of them i have gow2 halo3 cod 4 & 5 but i also love oblivion and fallout 3 i see them as equal

Pixie214
offline
Pixie214
5,838 posts
Peasant

I prefer FPS IO'm not a big fan of RPG's. But a good game is a good game what ever the genre or style.

Surlent
offline
Surlent
77 posts
Nomad

there's no better answer in that because we all think different

Veobahamut
offline
Veobahamut
887 posts
Nomad

I play both ive completed most Final fantasy games and i play Counter strike: Source.

epikk
offline
epikk
3 posts
Nomad

I play both RPG and FPS however I just love RPG and I would chose them over shooting games any time.

which genre you like better is a matter of taste. if you like shooting everything in sight or playing a mafia boss or soldier then you probably like first person shooters better, if you like to explore huge maps with almost no limits to what you can do then you'll like role playing games better.

Raxel
offline
Raxel
129 posts
Nomad

Apples VS Shoes

...It's that different, comparison is pointless.

komand
offline
komand
2 posts
Nomad

hmmmm.. IF you like em both you should try FallOut 3 The Pit - FPSRPG!

DSM
offline
DSM
1,303 posts
Nomad

I like RPG more but both of them is good

sourwhatup2
offline
sourwhatup2
3,660 posts
Jester

I say FPS just cause I'm addicted to Crossfire: Online Military Shooter.

But RPG is good too x.x

FireflyIV
offline
FireflyIV
3,224 posts
Nomad

Interesting thread. They both have pros and cons.

In my mind FPS are a lot of fun because of the multiplayer package. They have so much potential due to Xbox Live and the PS3 equivalent, eg Halo 3 and COD4. They are also great fun to play with mates. Is there anything more satisfying than slotting your friend in the head with a .50?

RPGs though give you a great sense of personal achievement. Oblivion IV, in my mind the best rpg on the 360, took me around 72 hours of gameplay to complete. I became head of all 3 main guilds and completed most of the notable side missions as well as the main quest of course. There's just something very satisfying completing a massive game and thinking back to when you started out.

So, for solo play, RPG, for multiplayer, FPS. If I had to choose I would go for RPG, purely because Zelda Ocarina of Time was my first love.

jboy85
offline
jboy85
69 posts
Nomad

It all depends on the RPG. If it's turn based then I think FPS is better since I'm not a fan of turn-based RPG's (except for Sonny). If it's an action RPG like Fable then I love it more than FPS. I guess it really depend on the games, I'm a fan of both but I think I like FPS more than RPG.

Iqs
offline
Iqs
14 posts
Nomad

I think FPS are better, because u need skills for killing people and not just the right equipment.

Showing 16-30 of 45