ForumsSupport ForumAP loss from ban

34 4367
Zega
offline
Zega
6,917 posts
Peasant

If a person gets banned, he/she should lose a number of armorpoints depending on what he/she did. Just a suggestion...

  • 34 Replies
Pixie214
offline
Pixie214
5,837 posts
Peasant

I supose it would add more weight behind the ban especially if they wre banned for spaimming so obviously points is what they care about.

Wigginometry
offline
Wigginometry
689 posts
Nomad

Heh, then in the box that shows posts and comments etc. there could be a ban counter to show everyone how much you fail.

I imagine a 100 point deduction would make a lot of people think before breaking the rules, though in some circumstances newbies might get the wrong end of this without really intending to. We all know enough of them don't read the stickies as it is.

ShintetsuWA
offline
ShintetsuWA
3,137 posts
Nomad

They can't just delete AP out of the blue ; the post/comment/rate counter wouldn't add up
correctly. This would bring up a lot of questions from those that are banned. Getting banned
should be punishment enough.

LufffiStudios
offline
LufffiStudios
1,420 posts
Nomad

Getting banned
should be punishment enough.


It also depends on how long you have been active on Armor Games. if you want a penalty such as mass point deduction, perhaps it should be focused on the slightly older users. the old punishments should be kept for the new users, seeing as how..they're new.
nichodemus
offline
nichodemus
14,998 posts
Grand Duke

They can't just delete AP out of the blue ; the post/comment/rate counter wouldn't add up
correctly. This would bring up a lot of questions from those that are banned. Getting banned
should be punishment enough.


They do deduct points. There was a user (jirocks?) who told me he got a temp ban and a 600 point deduction. Try asking him. And he got ban for a wrong reason. He was an innocent person.
Cenere
offline
Cenere
13,655 posts
Jester

They do deduct points. There was a user (jirocks?) who told me he got a temp ban and a 600 point deduction. Try asking him. And he got ban for a wrong reason. He was an innocent person.

Possibly because of a lot of comments being deleted? Mods cannot delete ap. They can delete posts and comments, but that is all.
nichodemus
offline
nichodemus
14,998 posts
Grand Duke

Possibly because of a lot of comments being deleted? Mods cannot delete ap. They can delete posts and comments, but that is all.


Nah, he got banned for posting an inappropriate link on Carlie's profile to report it...At least that's what he told me.
Cenere
offline
Cenere
13,655 posts
Jester

Nah, he got banned for posting an inappropriate link on Carlie's profile to report it...At least that's what he told me.

Again, whatever he did is not the reason for the loss of AP. Not directly, at least.
nichodemus
offline
nichodemus
14,998 posts
Grand Duke

Again, whatever he did is not the reason for the loss of AP. Not directly, at least.


Hmm...who knows what secret powers mods have hiding up their sleeves? Then again better not ask.
WackWeeper
offline
WackWeeper
198 posts
Nomad

yeah, AP loss due to banning sounds like a cool idea... maybe some sanctions first like maybe beside the user's frame there's a profile status.

example:

1st Warning = close monitor (banned few days)
2nd Warning = probation (banned few days -400AP)
final Warning = strict probation (banned few days -800AP)
kicked = deactivated (profile is deactivated)

just a suggestion.

Cenere
offline
Cenere
13,655 posts
Jester

Hmm...who knows what secret powers mods have hiding up their sleeves? Then again better not ask.

Well, it has been denied last time this suggestion was up. And I think Carlie said something about it as well, but not quite sure...

Anyway, now I can see why this would be an awefully evil punishment for people who care about the AP...
But then again, spamming usually is follwed by the spam being deleted, flaming is usually followed by banning, and flammers does not care about AP...
nichodemus
offline
nichodemus
14,998 posts
Grand Duke

Anyway, now I can see why this would be an awefully evil punishment for people who care about the AP...
But then again, spamming usually is follwed by the spam being deleted, flaming is usually followed by banning, and flammers does not care about AP...


Spammers usually get away with it....in the Comments for game. Every single comment goes along the lines of 'Boring', 'Worthless', '7/10'...and the like. If the mods deleted them the palce will look like a Christmas Tree without the decorations. And the leaves.

Aside from that...deducting AP isn't such a bad idea. Though I wouldn't suggest 400 AP at a go....
Cenere
offline
Cenere
13,655 posts
Jester

Spammers usually get away with it....in the Comments for game. Every single comment goes along the lines of 'Boring', 'Worthless', '7/10'...and the like. If the mods deleted them the palce will look like a Christmas Tree without the decorations. And the leaves.

Well, I feel with them. Going through 20+ pages of those comments, deleting all of them, and trying to find proper comments...
Worst thing is, I would find it terribly amusing... Must be my evil side.

Aside from that...deducting AP isn't such a bad idea. Though I wouldn't suggest 400 AP at a go....

Is that for regulars, or for newbies not knowing a thing?
nichodemus
offline
nichodemus
14,998 posts
Grand Duke

Is that for regulars, or for newbies not knowing a thing?


Perhaps deduct AP for repeated offenders who come here often. They are the one's who will keep coming back after temp bans and besides they should already know the exact rules. It's hard on newcomers just to deduct AP for offences. Plus a negative AP Score would look terrible on profiles...
Cenere
offline
Cenere
13,655 posts
Jester

Aye. Also, if we look at the top 100, how many there are not going to cry snot after loosing, say, 50 AP. More will make them get angry at the mods, really (coughTenniscough*).

*Before christmas.

Showing 1-15 of 34