I give 8/10. Why? For any user I don't recognise, I'd give a default 5. For a user I remember never to have gotten in any trouble with me, I add points, more if you've got a lot of forum posts. For using proper spelling and grammar, I add another point.
I'd like to take this opportunity to remind people that fear is a form of respect >
6ish/10. I'm not sure whether your bursting our counting bubble increased or decreased it, but your general postings are good. Slight detraction for once going along on flaming-lulz. :P
Most of the mods are ok people but I don't respect to an unreal scale like 10/10 or 9/10. I always respect ma friends more or why else would they be friends?