ForumsGamesfable

18 3710
crazyclive
offline
crazyclive
44 posts
Nomad

which is better fable 1 or 2?

  • 18 Replies
Lieutenut
offline
Lieutenut
1,251 posts
Nomad

I love both of them but fable 2 is better.... I just wish it still had the guildmaster in it though =]

Pois0nArr0w
offline
Pois0nArr0w
2,053 posts
Nomad

Fable II definitely. Just wish they had more armor pieces :P

Ya know the third installment is coming some time in '10.

theawesomeclint
offline
theawesomeclint
78 posts
Nomad

both are good but the second one is way better

New999
offline
New999
117 posts
Blacksmith

Fable 2.

while Fable was good it just wasnt better then Fable 2.

the thing ill miss from Fable though is the Reaper's Scythe.

spydawson
offline
spydawson
62 posts
Nomad

fable 1 and 2 are both my favorites its hard to diside

FloydTC
offline
FloydTC
2,906 posts
Nomad

fable 2 I guess.

Somers
offline
Somers
1,532 posts
Nomad

fableb 2c needs to be longer

Klaushouse
offline
Klaushouse
2,770 posts
Nomad

Fable 1. Sequel tried to be too much and felt really silly.

FireflyIV
offline
FireflyIV
3,224 posts
Nomad

Fable 1 was better for its time. Fable 2, seemed to lack direction, and tried to attempt too many different things. The detail of the game was amazing, but it seriously lacked lifetime. Not to mention you couldn't get armour any more. What's up with that? Once you'd bought the master weapons, which were far too easy to obtain in my opinion, there was pretty much nothing meaningful to spend your money on.

Thyll
offline
Thyll
476 posts
Nomad

Fable. Even with all the flaws, it was great.
Fable 2 is just what Fable 1 puked out after to many health potions...
Like the map. WTF?! I get a dog instead?! That doesn't even make any sense! And the story? The Bard from the first one would be ashamed!

xMoose
offline
xMoose
22 posts
Nomad

I enjoyed Fable 1 far more than 2. Two looked better but the storyline was weak and it seemed that Lionhead tried too hard, ruining the fun.

chocolateeggos
offline
chocolateeggos
50 posts
Nomad

although i actually never owned fable 2 ive played and beaten both and for me they are tied while fable 1 had a better story overall the multiplayer part of the second was just great

FireflyIV
offline
FireflyIV
3,224 posts
Nomad

although i actually never owned fable 2 ive played and beaten both and for me they are tied while fable 1 had a better story overall the multiplayer part of the second was just great


I diagree. I'm a bit of a purist when it comes to RPG. Multiplayer was a bad idea. I know so many people who just got one of their friends who'd already had the game to just send them 1 million gold. Where's the challenge in that?
alex2222
offline
alex2222
16 posts
Nomad

fable 1 coz fable 2 was 2 short which killed it for me

ellame
offline
ellame
49 posts
Nomad

I actually don't think I have a favorite between the two. I think the games did a lot of things right, and also had a lot of mistakes. If you put the two together, though? That would be a pretty incredible game. For instance...

I liked having armor. Why doesn't armor exist in Fable 2? Like, my friend downloaded the expansions and was saying something about armor, but you can't include something in only an expansion and consider it part of the game.

I loved the whole real-estate, economy simulator. After a good day of buying and fixing and renting, I was almost a millionare. So it was definitely a good idea making it so you didn't have to kill a person in order to buy their house.

I like that magic is actually useful in Fable 2. I didn't use a single spell besides heal life in the first Fable, because it just wasn't necessary. Ever.

I liked that you aged in Fable 1, though it happens too quickly. I'm the sort of loser who spends hours training right at the beginning of a game, so I usually was about 55 by the third mission. I still like the idea of growing up and having the world grow around you. I think they should implement more things like cities becoming more or less developed, statues being erected, bridges being built. It was a good level of immersion that was under utilized in my opinion.

Showing 1-15 of 18