ForumsGamesBattle of the Video Games

55 6734
shayneii
offline
shayneii
2,492 posts
Peasant

Hey, just thought this up. I know there are other "Battle of" threads, but those are mostly popular media threads. So I thought of this. Vote and suggest games for the next Battle!

Rules:
1. You must post a reason why you vote for a game.
2. Once a game gets 10 votes, it will win.
3. No spamming please. If it's not about the current topic (voting, or a suggestion) then please don't post it here
4. This is for fun! No arguing please, keep it to your profiles

So with that... I will start off the first battle, which will be:

Halo 3
vs.
Call of Duty 4

Vote for your favourite, and make sure you post reasons why you vote!

  • 55 Replies
shayneii
offline
shayneii
2,492 posts
Peasant

Oh... and to keep things simple... it will be based on the next-gen version of games (PS3, 360, and Wii versions).

And please bold your answer in your post when voting!

master565
offline
master565
4,101 posts
Nomad

halo 3 i just dont like call of duty games cause u die to easyly

shayneii
offline
shayneii
2,492 posts
Peasant

Cool.

Halo 3: 1
Call of Duty 4: 0

And I agree, you die way to easily in Call of Duty... especially when I play against my friend... he is too skilled lol.

florglee2
offline
florglee2
1,778 posts
Peasant

Ah, hell, Halo 3. At that point, Bungie wasn't totally ridiculous, so they still put in an effort. And can I suggest Fallout 3 VS GTA IV? They're both fee roam, with plenty of options and desicions, but they have totally differing themes.

Owen135731
offline
Owen135731
2,123 posts
Peasant

COD 4. It has better online play in my opinion. And i find the voice acting to be better.

Shayneii, if you keep dying, why not use juggernaut?

shayneii
offline
shayneii
2,492 posts
Peasant

Halo 3: 3
Call of Duty 4: 1

[quote=florglee2]can I suggest Fallout 3 VS GTA IV? They're both fee roam, with plenty of options and desicions, but they have totally differing themes.[/quote]

Definitely, sounds good! That can be the next one

[quote=Owen135731]Shayneii, if you keep dying, why not use juggernaut?[/quote]

What's that? Sorry I don't play it much mostly at my friend's house :P

Seyulshehir
offline
Seyulshehir
136 posts
Nomad

If you keep dying in CoD4 it's very simple, get better. Keep playing and you'll eventually get better if you have patience. So my vote is for Call of Duty 4 even though I know it probably' won't win.

Anyway, for the next battle after Fallout 3 and GTA IV, can I suggest No More Heroes and Okami? I find them both to be similar in the semi-free roaming; and they both wreak of Japanese influence, Okami bearing ancient influence and NMH more modern. So they aren't incredibly similar but both blend comedy and drama beautifully, so that's my suggestion.

Owen135731
offline
Owen135731
2,123 posts
Peasant

can I suggest No More Heroes and Okami? I find them both to be similar in the semi-free roaming; and they both wreak of Japanese influence, Okami bearing ancient influence and NMH more modern. So they aren't incredibly similar but both blend comedy and drama beautifully, so that's my suggestion.


I can guarantee you 75% of the people haven't played both of those games (I have). Since NMH is Wii exclusive, and Okami is only for PS2/Wii.
pauler94
offline
pauler94
2,513 posts
Nomad

Call of Duty 4. The online is so sick. I have a PS3, but I know for sure that Halo gets boring after like a day. Call of Duty games never get boring.

Redspring
offline
Redspring
15 posts
Nomad

Call of Duty 4, because I never played Halo 3

undertkr666
offline
undertkr666
33 posts
Nomad

[b]Halo 3,because you have to work more for the kill besides a few weapons and headshots. CoD has a self aiming system which i dont like.

valkyrie1119
offline
valkyrie1119
1,720 posts
Nomad

Oh jeez, this is going to be one hell of a choice. I really like both, but I think in the end I choose Halo 3 because I am better at it and it includes vehicles and all sorts of things that make it really cool. If I could vote for both, that would be my vote.

shayneii
offline
shayneii
2,492 posts
Peasant

Halo 3: 5
COD4: 4

Intense battle... lol

Too bad I can't really get better at COD... I only play it when I'm at my friend's house.

BalanarXIII
offline
BalanarXIII
58 posts
Nomad

Halo 3. Cod 4 doesn't have as good live as Halo 3.

Drakedurbin
offline
Drakedurbin
200 posts
Nomad

master 565 said: halo 3 i just dont like call of duty games cause u die to easyly
What difficulty did you play Halo 3 on, man? It's not exactly just running up to the biggest dude and meleein him to death on anything above easy. And I have actually played both on singleplayer (beat em) and on multiplayer and I say CoD4. I absolutely love Halo 3, and I pride myself on my abilities on it... but CoD4 is better in almost every sense. There can be more in multiplayer, they have upgrades such as martrydom (go Marty!!!!! :P ), the story in much more in-depth, the music isn't the same 2 songs over and over again, and the controls are surpringly quick to pick up. Sure, in Halo 3 you can learn them in 2 minutes. I learned Cod4's as soon as I started the game. But still, I've played CoD4 on the Xbox 360 (singleplayer only though except for splitscreen) and the PC (everything... even a clan). For Halo 3, I only played it on the Xbox 360 and it was only like 3 days of online in it. I had internet problems and I couldn't get on. But for what I've played in a half-year of CoD4 and the 3 days of Halo 3, CoD4 was better. Sorry I made this so long.
Showing 1-15 of 55