ForumsGamesGuitar Hero or Rock Band

32 5033
Centie
offline
Centie
251 posts
Nomad

Which one is better? State your opinion.

  • 32 Replies
shayneii
offline
shayneii
2,492 posts
Peasant

and you think they took time with the tons of track packs they realeased within a couple of years?


Those are just addons. Downloadadble content. Why do you think there are only 5 Rock Band games, and two main titles: RB1 and RB2. Then there's The Beatles (legendary), Unplugged for PSP only, and Lego RB.

Let me name the GH games off the top of my head.

GH1.
GH2.
GH3.
GH World Tour.
GH5.
Band Hero.
GH: On Tour.
GH: On Tour: Decades.
GH: On Tour: Modern Hits.
GH: Metallica.
GH: Van Halen.

Later... I had to consult wiki, and found even more...

GH: Aerosmith
GH: Rocks the 80's
GH: Smash Hits.

Point proven?

Also Guitar Hero Metallica took way longer to make than any other rock band game.


Not a reason that it is better... at all.
XxSacredxX
offline
XxSacredxX
34 posts
Nomad

IM still Guitar Hero, some of my favorite songs r there

cingcon
offline
cingcon
152 posts
Nomad

ROCKBAND!! I hate people wholike Guitar Hero, and I used to play guitar hero so dont think that i dont have the right idea. rockbands instruments are much more creative and THEY MADE THE DRUMS AND MICROPHONE!! and if you say that rockband copied guitar hero your wrong again because both conpanies helped design the original guitar hero, they just split up. The rock band people used to be the guitar hero people so there. And some of the guitar hero solos are really sketchy and the buttons aren't in sync even if you calabarate it.
AND!!!! (i'm not done yet) PEOPLE WHO SAY GUITAR HERO IS BETTER BECAUSE THE NOTES ARE ROUND ARE THE PEOLPLE WHO ANNOY ME THE MOST!!!! IT DOESN'T MATTER ABOUT THE SHAPE OF THE NOTES!!!
-now i'm done

EnterOrion
offline
EnterOrion
4,220 posts
Nomad

Guitar Hero.

Rock Band annoys me. It just does.

And it doesn't have Metallica specific games, now does it?

Centie
offline
Centie
251 posts
Nomad

Let me name the GH games off the top of my head.

GH1.
GH2.
GH3.
GH World Tour.
GH5.
Band Hero.
GH: On Tour.
GH: On Tour: Decades.
GH: On Tour: Modern Hits.
GH: Metallica.
GH: Van Halen.

Later... I had to consult wiki, and found even more...

GH: Aerosmith
GH: Rocks the 80's
GH: Smash Hits.

Point proven?



First of all guitar hero started 2 years earlier second of all they have different departments in which they make different games and third of all you missed out the mobile games and arcade games.
johnny294
offline
johnny294
284 posts
Nomad

rock band because the songs are better and you can play drums bass guitar microphone, but the guitar hero guitar is better

marioman327
offline
marioman327
290 posts
Nomad

AND!!!! (i'm not done yet) PEOPLE WHO SAY GUITAR HERO IS BETTER BECAUSE THE NOTES ARE ROUND ARE THE PEOLPLE WHO ANNOY ME THE MOST!!!! IT DOESN'T MATTER ABOUT THE SHAPE OF THE NOTES!!!


Actually it makes a humongous difference. I can beat any song on guitar hero on expert, but I majorly fail at RB, JUST because of the square notes. And besides, GH is better for a lot more reasons than that
shayneii
offline
shayneii
2,492 posts
Peasant

First of all guitar hero started 2 years earlier second of all they have different departments in which they make different games and


2 years earlier? So since 2005, that's around 5 years. That makes... on average "2.8" games a year, and they're making them even faster now.

Rock Band... since the end of 2007. That's 3 years. So... "1.6" games a year. And one is a special PSP only game.

third of all you missed out the mobile games and arcade games.


I think you proved my point... even more GH games...
Graham
offline
Graham
8,047 posts
Nomad

AND!!!! (i'm not done yet) PEOPLE WHO SAY GUITAR HERO IS BETTER BECAUSE THE NOTES ARE ROUND ARE THE PEOLPLE WHO ANNOY ME THE MOST!!!! IT DOESN'T MATTER ABOUT THE SHAPE OF THE NOTES!!![quote]Actually it makes a humongous difference. I can beat any song on guitar hero on expert, but I majorly fail at RB, JUST because of the square notes. And besides, GH is better for a lot more reasons than that
[/quote]

2nd'd

GH is so much easier with hammer-ons too. I can almost beat (w/o nofail) Devil Went Down to Georgia on EXP. I failed a rolling stones song on Rock Band in Best Buy.
cobrakarate
offline
cobrakarate
104 posts
Nomad

i dunno if someone is interested in guitar hero-Aerosmith on PS2 comment on my page and i mkight be ale to work something out

Snakefothers
offline
Snakefothers
32 posts
Nomad

I find Guitar Hero more fun. I think its because more people have it so you can always find people to rock with. But thats just my opinion.

delossantosj
offline
delossantosj
6,670 posts
Nomad

guitar hero 5 is better then all of the games so far.

gh 1 and 2 vs.. blank gh wins

gh3 vs rockband gh wins

gh world tour vs. rockband 2 rockband wins

gh5 vs. all gh5 wins

delossantosj
offline
delossantosj
6,670 posts
Nomad

[quoteThere basically the same thing but rock band (even if its more expensive) did come up with the idea of the band before guitar hero.[/quote]

fail. gh was already making world tour before rockband had started being made. they just made it first and now everyone thinks gh is a rip off of guitar hero

delossantosj
offline
delossantosj
6,670 posts
Nomad

pardon me allow me to fix my quote....

There basically the same thing but rock band (even if its more expensive) did come up with the idea of the band before guitar hero.
2014631
offline
2014631
1,854 posts
Nomad

Guitair hero. No comparison

Showing 16-30 of 32