ForumsWEPRDisproving god

352 64477
skater_kid_who_pwns
offline
skater_kid_who_pwns
4,375 posts
Blacksmith

So I just have a question to every one. What is the point in proving god to not exist? What makes it worth while to sit and flip out on people, the goverment, schools, kids, parents.....that they are wrong, and science is wrong?

I understand having an oppinion, and trying to get others to beilve that. But Have any of you heard of Pascals wager?

What he said was basically, if you belive in god, and he is real, you lived a good live, and if you belive in god, and he's not real, you lost nothing, but lived a life of good morals, which I will touch on in a second. However, If he is real, and you didn't beilve you go to hell. And if you didn't beilve and he isn't real, then you lost nothing, other then being remembered as a person who didn't care about morals.


I would like you to go read the ten commandments, and the other moral wrongs in the bible. How are ANY of them bad?

All I'm really trying to gather here, is what is the point in tryign to prove god as fake? Why does it matter if you beilve in god? And what do you lose by beilveing in him?

  • 352 Replies
wolf1991
offline
wolf1991
3,437 posts
Farmer

Matter is something that occupies space and can be perceived by one or more senses.


Ever hear of Dark Matter? And regardless your argument is still childish and I refuse to accept it as such until you have given me proof.
Legion1350
offline
Legion1350
5,365 posts
Nomad

Ever hear of Dark Matter? And regardless your argument is still childish and I refuse to accept it as such until you have given me proof.


Very well wolf. I think you can have a turn. I want you to convince me that dark matter exists. This is not an insult, I am truly open to your argument.
MageGrayWolf
offline
MageGrayWolf
9,462 posts
Farmer

Very well wolf. I think you can have a turn. I want you to convince me that dark matter exists. This is not an insult, I am truly open to your argument.


Explanation of what it is.
http://science.nasa.gov/astrophysics/focus-areas/what-is-dark-energy/

Proof of existence.
http://www.nasa.gov/home/hqnews/2006/aug/HQ_06297_CHANDRA_Dark_Matter.html
wolf1991
offline
wolf1991
3,437 posts
Farmer

Thanks mage

Legion1350
offline
Legion1350
5,365 posts
Nomad

Thank you mage. Now I at least see no reason why there isn't a possibility that dark matter exists. If I understood that correctly, dark matter is what prevents all other solid, physical matter (planets, stars, etc..) from flying apart, correct?

DDX
offline
DDX
3,562 posts
Nomad

proving god.. (sidenote did not read anything in the last 27 pages. b/c idrc)

>even the atheist understands the concept of that nothing greater can be conceived.

> it is better to exist in reality than to exist in the mind alone.
so if the greatest thing that is understood in the mind, must exist in reality, because of the concept. so god, that than which nothing greater can be conceived exists in reality.

so that which nothing greater can be thought must of logical necessity exist since, existence is greater than non- existence. hence, what must be is greater than what could be. Or to speak more clearly, a being whose existence is necessary is a more perfect being than one whose existence is not necessary.

>exstience is greater than non -existence
> that than which nothing greater can be conceived would inf act be greater if it existed
>that than which nothing greater can be conceived can not be thought as not existing since it can be thought
Therefore: that than which nothing greater can be conceived must exist.

since "god" is a perfect being then he must be understood to exist because existence is logically implied by perfection.

derp. umad skater?

Thank you mage. Now I at least see no reason why there isn't a possibility that dark matter exists. If I understood that correctly, dark matter is what prevents all other solid, physical matter (planets, stars, etc..) from flying apart, correct?

... srsly
grimml
offline
grimml
879 posts
Nomad

so if the greatest thing that is understood in the mind, must exist in reality, because of the concept


Sorry, but that's NO PROOF!
WlZARD
offline
WlZARD
26 posts
Nomad

God is just about as hard to disprove as he is to prove. I say just let people believe what they want, and get on with your day...

MoonFairy
offline
MoonFairy
3,386 posts
Shepherd

God is just about as hard to disprove as he is to prove. I say just let people believe what they want, and get on with your day...

I'm with you on this one Wizard.

Why do you have to prove that God Exists/ Doesn't Exist? Is it that important to you to try and change someones personal opinion?
wolf1991
offline
wolf1991
3,437 posts
Farmer

since "god" is a perfect being then he must be understood to exist because existence is logically implied by perfection.


There is no such thing as perfection, the universe by its very own nature is the antithesis of perfection.

Why do you have to prove that God Exists/ Doesn't Exist? Is it that important to you to try and change someones personal opinion?


I don't have to, however I would prefer the masses to be more educated.
Parsat
offline
Parsat
2,180 posts
Blacksmith

There is no such thing as perfection, the universe by its very own nature is the antithesis of perfection.


Lack of something is a crappy proof for its nonexistence.
wolf1991
offline
wolf1991
3,437 posts
Farmer

Lack of something is a crappy proof for its nonexistence.


It's also crappy proof for its existence
MRWalker82
offline
MRWalker82
4,005 posts
Shepherd

If something lacks proof then the only reasonable position is to say that you are unsure and as such cannot make an assertion either to the positive or the negative regarding such a thing. For example I have not seen any proof that there are alien lifeforms flying spaceships through our atmosphere so I don't say that there are. However I also cannot conclusively say that there are not, although the complete lack of evidence would shift the likelihood of such a situation to being most likely false.

I am the same way with my atheism. I have looked and looked and not found any concrete evidence for the existence of any deity, so I do not say that there are any. However I cannot flat out say that there are no deities because I could be wrong. However due to the overwhelming lack of evidence, and the obvious contradiction and falsehoods contained in what many people use as evidence, make such a being highly unlikely, and even more unlikely if it is at all similar to what popular religious texts claim.

IcyIndia
offline
IcyIndia
1,344 posts
Nomad

f something lacks proof then the only reasonable position is to say that you are unsure and as such cannot make an assertion either to the positive or the negative regarding such a thing.


Exactly. We just don't know enough about reality to be able to actually state "facts"
MRWalker82
offline
MRWalker82
4,005 posts
Shepherd

Sure we do, however we have to understand that simply because something is a fact doesn't mean that there is not a minute chance of it being incorrect. We know gravitational forces are a fact, however there is a possibility that it may be incorrect. However it is true enough so much of the time and in so many situations that we can say that it is a fact.

Showing 256-270 of 352