Forums → Games → Red Dead Redemption vs Call of Duty Modern Warfare 2

How can you compare these? when i play rdr i think NOTHING about mw. and people who say all you do is shoot in mw, thats really the point in a shooter like that. if you want to compare something to mw go with Halo or Resistance

hellz itz rdr!

but ya shudnt compare those games

RDR is like an old western GTA in a way. MW2 isn't any better than any other war game out there; it just has a better reputation.

RDR wins for me, because I don't like war games and I especially dislike CoD.

These games are in a different genre.. I see the comparison, but the only thing that should be compared is the online gameplay.. I go with Red Dead, even though i hate that game.. I hate nothing more than MW2, sold that game a long arse time ago

Dude, how can you compare a game based on the wild west dying to a modern combat action game?? But I would rather play, RDR

I say RDR because i like games with more things to do than just shooting.

you can compare the gameplay, controls, story, ect.

very different comparison

oooohhhh tuffy...... i wud have to say.... mw2

I have played MW2 and i liked it but i looked at red dead redemption and it was almost love at first sight

i like bad company 2

Modern Warfare 2 !

modern warfare because of the online which i gives me endless fun

Wow heres a tough decision I rlly Luv both games they both seem to be jst Fun to play n wen it comes to Multiplayer both games r best at it.

Well its rlly a pick between Cowboys and Soldiers
Hummh I say... CoD Modern Warfare 2.