ForumsThe TavernMore Constructive Feedback on Games

20 4340
Rofegme
offline
Rofegme
87 posts
Nomad

I have seen recently that the feedback on games are usually like this:

"awesome" "[number]/10" "i dont get it" "fun" "i like it" &quotretty good" "lame" "cool" "lol"

and so on...

I think it would be better if people gave more constructive feedback on games... how should "lame" help? Yes, the author of the game now knows that some people don't enjoy his/her game. But what part should he improve? What do people want the part they don't like to be like?

Even criticism like "awesome" doesn't help much either... other than to encourage the author that people enjoy his game. People should include what they didn't like (if any), and suggestions for the author too.

  • 20 Replies
Graham
offline
Graham
8,047 posts
Nomad

Only the forum has the shield of moderation. Outside this homey place is one of demons plaguing poor souls. Though, there may be wounds slashed upon these foul beasts, they shall never be defeated with our current firepower.

1337Player
offline
1337Player
1,766 posts
Peasant

The reason the comments are like

"awesome" "[number]/10" "i dont get it" "fun" "i like it" &quotretty good" "lame" "cool" "lol"
is that people just want AP. They spam the comments to get AP and get known. I would know this because when I first joined the site I did that. But now I just stick to the forums and probably give a long response to a game that was submitted on the front page.

I do think there should be an amount of words requirement so people can't spam. Hopefully someday there will be.
CommanderDude7
offline
CommanderDude7
4,689 posts
Nomad

Yup its all for the spam. Its so delicious that people cant stop.

ExboMarker
offline
ExboMarker
316 posts
Nomad

Like 133player said. People just want to gain AP fast. Personally when I play a game I will sometimes leave a 10 word comment. But I usually try to go more in depth.

Voyageur
offline
Voyageur
79 posts
Nomad

I have seen this too, whenever I comment on a game, I try to be more contructive than just a few words. That bugs me too.

Joe96
offline
Joe96
2,226 posts
Nomad

Yeah, people do that, but I don't usually mind, except this one time I saw this guy spammed "good" 6 times in a row.

Rofegme
offline
Rofegme
87 posts
Nomad

I do think there should be an amount of words requirement so people can't spam. Hopefully someday there will be.


Yes, I hope there would be an amount of word requirement soon. That would really put down the spam... unless people just repeat the same world over and over again or add unnecessary amount of punctuation marks.. xD
1337Player
offline
1337Player
1,766 posts
Peasant

unless people just repeat the same world over and over again or add unnecessary amount of punctuation marks

I thought about that... it's kind of sad how people go so far just to gain AP.
Lintire
offline
Lintire
114 posts
Nomad

You can't force people to comment for anything other then the AP - it's not like you have to read the reviews, they're only there for a quick boost. People will always play the system to get it in their advantage - it's not something you can help, and it will always happen.

Merits exist to encourage people to comment decently. Although they aren't much as a way of an AP fix for the time they take to write, they do give a boost and they look good on a profile for bragging's sake to boot. That's how you encourage people to comment, you don't force them to - not all people even know how to comment.

Google567
offline
Google567
4,013 posts
Farmer

Only the forum has the shield of moderation. Outside this homey place is one of demons plaguing poor souls. Though, there may be wounds slashed upon these foul beasts, they shall never be defeated with our current firepower.
I have to agree with all of this, what are we going to do? Have a mod patrol the games for spammers all the time instead of focusing on things they can do to help the overall site?
vinster132
offline
vinster132
5,874 posts
Jester

is that people just want AP. They spam the comments to get AP and get known. I would know this because when I first joined the site I did that. But now I just stick to the forums and probably give a long response to a game that was submitted on the front page.

I don't like people who like AP and spam for it. It's just stupid. AP isn't your life. AP doesn't affect your life. It doesn't help you in life. Spamming for it won't help. You'll get caught and get banned.
Have a mod patrol the games for spammers all the time instead of focusing on things they can do to help the overall site?

No it's fine the way it is. Too much work for a mod.
locoace3
offline
locoace3
15,053 posts
Nomad

is that people just want AP. They spam the comments to get AP and get known. I would know this because when I first joined the site I did that. But now I just stick to the forums and probably give a long response to a game that was submitted on the front page.

I don't like people who like AP and spam for it. It's just stupid. AP isn't your life. AP doesn't affect your life. It doesn't help you in life. Spamming for it won't help. You'll get caught and get banned.

Have a mod patrol the games for spammers all the time instead of focusing on things they can do to help the overall site?

No it's fine the way it is. Too much work for a mod.


we actually should have volunteer mods that aren't full mods but are trustworthy people who will take AP and ban spammers on game
vinster132
offline
vinster132
5,874 posts
Jester

we actually should have volunteer mods that aren't full mods but are trustworthy people who will take AP and ban spammers on game

There are 1600+ games on here. It's. Too. Much. Work. Period.
1337Player
offline
1337Player
1,766 posts
Peasant

we actually should have volunteer mods that aren't full mods but are trustworthy people who will take AP and ban spammers on game

That's a great idea but a lot of things could go wrong there. If only people were more trustworthy.
Voyageur
offline
Voyageur
79 posts
Nomad

Yeah, people do that, but I don't usually mind, except this one time I saw this guy spammed "good" 6 times in a row.


That kinda happened to me, it posted my comment three times in a row. Probably not his fault.
Showing 1-15 of 20