ForumsGamesPlaystation Move V.S Microsoft Kinect V.S Nintendo Wii

46 10019
Indiagamerz
offline
Indiagamerz
77 posts
Nomad

Which of these three motion controls systems would you say is best.
PlayStation Move
Microsoft Kinect
Nintendo Wii

  • 46 Replies
zachshw2
offline
zachshw2
74 posts
Peasant

hey your really stupid you now that? microsoft kinect?
umm no its not a game system at all and its called xbox kinect

lllllllllllllllllll
offline
lllllllllllllllllll
187 posts
Nomad

Well, Wii did had the idea of like sensor bars and sensor remotes, but I thing Microsoft and Playstation did copy that idea. You know?

Elitemagical
offline
Elitemagical
1,207 posts
Nomad

umm no its not a game system at all and its called xbox kinect


What the Hell are you talking about? Simply because Microsoft Kinect is a peripheral instead of a separate console, does not mean it should not be in competition with Microsoft's contender's motion control products. Furthermore, it's not marketed as Xbox Kinect either, it's simply Kinect.

Which of these three motion controls systems would you say is best.
PlayStation Move
Microsoft Kinect
Nintendo Wii


From what I understood Kinect and Move have not been released yet, so how could you effectively judge? The Nintendo Wii is pretty powerful, and Nintendo started the revolution towards truly interactive gameplay, but it's lagging behind now, Sony have had quite a few more years to perfect their technologies now and the motion detection will be surprisingly superior, in my opinion. I would say however, Sony are not going to target their product at a younger generation of gamers, so the price tag on the thing isn't going to be as friendly as Nintendo Wii's.

I am unsure about Microsoft's Kinect, it looks like a PS2 Eye Toy, which was a tremendous failure. Maybe Microsoft will pull it off, but it it will either be too expensive for most casual/hardcore gamers or will not offer a good enough experience and Nintendo will continue their dominance over the motion control portion of the industry.
delossantosj
offline
delossantosj
6,672 posts
Nomad

i feel like they are all going to end up like the wii and fall behind and not be very fun unless its like bowling or something. but idk.

i feel like the kinect will start off with alot mroe of a bang then the move has had but it will slowly die out in like 6 months with the playstation move. there simply isnt a market for it.

now 3D gaming however will be HUGE. as soon as killzone 3 gets released its going to be the shiznats. and then xbox will adopt it also and then soon almost all games will be 3D i think

CruelAce
offline
CruelAce
71 posts
Nomad

I haven't used the Move or the Kinect, but from what I've heard, the Kinect will be the better one. But don't forget that the Wii came out over 2 years ago.

holt24
offline
holt24
1,133 posts
Nomad

I would say however, Sony are not going to target their product at a younger generation of gamers, so the price tag on the thing isn't going to be as friendly as Nintendo Wii's.


Actually move games will be 40 dollars.

Here a funny video of the move.


The move will very obviously be better than the wii I think but heres a reveiw.
zachshw2
offline
zachshw2
74 posts
Peasant

What the Hell are you talking about? Simply because Microsoft Kinect is a peripheral instead of a separate console, xbox 360 kinect is not a new console at all and people are too stupid to realize that. its just a camera that plugs into the xbox 360 thats it

shayneii
offline
shayneii
2,492 posts
Peasant

http://www.yaybuttons.com/

That is all.

holt24
offline
holt24
1,133 posts
Nomad

The links didn't work for me.

Voyageur
offline
Voyageur
79 posts
Nomad

Seeing as how neither of the later two are out yet... We'll find out for sure once they do come out. But it looks like the PS3 Move is be superior. And more accurate.

shayneii
offline
shayneii
2,492 posts
Peasant

AG glitch. Sorry, you can just type www.yaybuttons.com if the link doesn't work again.

delossantosj
offline
delossantosj
6,672 posts
Nomad

best link i eva seen

Drink
offline
Drink
1,621 posts
Blacksmith

wii was ok for a while but got boring ps3 and 360 have similair things coming out they will probably be able to handle alot better i deff wanna buy the ps3 move if i ever get that much money for it

Indiagamerz
offline
Indiagamerz
77 posts
Nomad

Sorry i meant to say which of these would you think is better because the Playstation Move just came out and the Kinect comes out in November

gigmyster
offline
gigmyster
53 posts
Nomad

I think motion controls are a totall gimmick. They offer very few immersive gameplay experiences. I know from experience with the wii that motion controls can be very frustrating and not really worth the few times that the controls work well. and from what I've heard the playstation move is the exact same thing as the wii. I really really truly hate motion controls. its just a gimmick so that the companies can charge you a crapload of money.

Showing 1-15 of 46