ForumsPopular MediaThe movie that was nothing like the book

40 14032
dudeguy45
offline
dudeguy45
2,917 posts
Peasant

What movie have you seen that was supposed to be the same story but was nothin like it?

  • 40 Replies
wolf1991
offline
wolf1991
3,437 posts
Farmer

that movie scared me away from the books, i had already read the first two and i have no intention of finishing the series right now. I got Eragon (movie) for my birthday and have watched it maybe once, i might watch it again sometime, hmmm


You're not missing much.

As for movies, well Lord of the Ring The Two Towers was nothing like the book.
thisisnotanalt
offline
thisisnotanalt
9,821 posts
Farmer

Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs.

/thread

TheGr8est
offline
TheGr8est
703 posts
Nomad

I agree that most movies are different from the books but making a movie is MUCH more difficult.

And did anybody realise that Sequels are usually MUCH worse than originals, except for when their based on books.

Example:Harry Potter
Twilight
Star Wars
R based on books and their sequels are better

atlantis
nanny mcphee
toy story 2-3
r not based on books and are not good sequels

Did anyone know
Cars 2 is supposed to come out later this year?

jets99
offline
jets99
599 posts
Nomad

Percy Jackson is WAY different then the book and the book was alot better to I think

tegan190
offline
tegan190
783 posts
Nomad

I am legend . . .they didn't even put in the part were the woman is running through the field..that's one of the biggest parts and they left it out..

sk8brder246
offline
sk8brder246
740 posts
Nomad

i always watch the movie first and one the rare occasion that i do read the book I'm always like wow this was nothing like the movie.

firetail_madness
offline
firetail_madness
20,591 posts
Blacksmith

Almost every movie that was made based on a book is not like the book, there's obvious not enough time to put all the book ideas into a 2/3 hour movie...


I agree completely...most books are reliant on thoughts to communicate ideas to the reader and it just doesn't flow well into movies.
purple73198
offline
purple73198
17 posts
Nomad

Percy Jackson and the Olympians, the Lightning Thief and Coraline

Femm
offline
Femm
42 posts
Farmer

The Kite Runner. They left so many important bits out, I couldn't believe it.

machinesway
offline
machinesway
101 posts
Nomad

I am Legend....they changed the ending from the one in the book, the ending in the book actually gives the title I am Legend the point, the ending defines the title.
that and pretty much most of that film was nothing like the book.

Kreitmaker
offline
Kreitmaker
290 posts
Jester

There was this book I read in English class called The Kite Runner (and Femm already mentioned it), which I rather liked a lot. Then my teacher showed the movie (which the teacher said that she didn't like showing the movie to us). When I saw the movie, I was like "UHHHHHHH..." It was barely like the book! If I have to go on a very late rant, I will! I get why the harelip was cut out, but the other cut out parts sucked. The boy in the present time was like happy in one scene, then the next scene (in America), he's randomly sad. Now I know why he's sad, but if you haven't read the book, you'd be like "The heck?". And the ending was a joke, the guy says this quote (I don't remember how it goes) like an idiot, runs off, and the credits start rolling. I imagined that part in a much better way than what the director made up. I could let this rant go on forever, but I'll stop. Nope, a few more words. The scene where the main character talks to his girlfriend was the best example of how this film sucked. Here they are, walking down the street, talking about something that'll spoil the plot if I told you. Now you'd think, not a big deal, right? Wrong! If you happen to look closely at the background, the girlfriend's mother is walking behind them, watching them as if they were kids. How awkward is that? That's enough for the year, can't believe I talked about a film from 2007 based upon a book from 2003.

ihsahn
offline
ihsahn
428 posts
Nomad

The Godfather has various subplots that the movie never even touches.
Fantastic movie and book though.

xAyjAy
offline
xAyjAy
4,710 posts
Blacksmith

there are so many movies that are based on a book. they have to shange things because they can not show thoughts and so. besides that, would you watch a movie that is at least three hours long?

Deth666
offline
Deth666
653 posts
Nomad

Braveheart is 3hrs long

Bluydee
offline
Bluydee
3,426 posts
Nomad

The Avengers. Read the origin story it was based off. Although the movie was better than the origin and comic.

Showing 16-30 of 40