ForumsSupport ForumExtra tavern-like forum for clever things

10 2139
DaoGao
offline
DaoGao
220 posts
Nomad

Why not make another forum for clever stuff? Like maths sequences, equations, paradoxes? Why not?

  • 10 Replies
GhostOfMatrix
offline
GhostOfMatrix
15,595 posts
Herald

I don't see how that would be necessary.

The Tavern is there for a reason. Just use it.

brp47
offline
brp47
580 posts
Peasant

daogao i dont like this. i have read your tavern post on equations and tbh its got no place on the forums in general. but the tavern covers everything and anything so i agree with matrix it's not really needed

Ghgt99
offline
Ghgt99
1,890 posts
Nomad

It even says "All topics and conversation without a proper category welcome". I mean, that is very broad. You put anything in there.

Cenere
offline
Cenere
13,657 posts
Jester

It even says "All topics and conversation without a proper category welcome". I mean, that is very broad. You put anything in there.

Italic emphasizing is mine*.
This means that most of the "clever discussions" could go in the World Event section, if you really want this properly discussed, or if you want a lighter take on something, put it in the Tavern.
I have seen many a philosophical thread in World Events, it is really just a - grown-up discussion, in some way.
What you suggest is simply just a hybrid between World Events and the Tavern, and in reality it just depends on how serious a discussion you want, and how likely your topic is to provoke ReligionVSAtheists!! arguments.
To some point, I would also say that equations and math problems for the sake of equations and math problems could easily be put in the forum games.

*As for the emphasizing in the quote: Not everything, no. I get pissy if you think you can put whatever in that section, and get away with it, just like I do when someone decides "Art, Music and Writing you made yourself" means "discuss your favourite band here, lol!"
Ghgt99
offline
Ghgt99
1,890 posts
Nomad

As for the emphasizing in the quote: Not everything, no. I get pissy if you think you can put whatever in that section, and get away with it, just like I do when someone decides "Art, Music and Writing you made yourself" means "discuss your favourite band here, lol!"


Yeah, but still. People should be able to read the section description. Sometimes I think the IQ of the spammers is a 1 digit number.
GhostOfMatrix
offline
GhostOfMatrix
15,595 posts
Herald

Sometimes I think the IQ of the spammers is a 1 digit number.

IQ has nothing to do with intellect, but I get your point.
*As for the emphasizing in the quote: Not everything, no. I get pissy if you think you can put whatever in that section, and get away with it, just like I do when someone decides "Art, Music and Writing you made yourself" means "discuss your favourite band here, lol!"

I agree with you.

I think that users should read the Forum-Rules before anything, then just lurk around for a few minutes before even posting.
Cenere
offline
Cenere
13,657 posts
Jester

Yeah, but still. People should be able to read the section description. Sometimes I think the IQ of the spammers is a 1 digit number.

Luckily I tend to evolve a habit of deleting such threads whenever it happens often. Because if they can't take the time to read the description, or god forbid it, the rules for the section, the thread was obviously not very important.

Anyway, I find that the thread about an awesome equation I saw in the Tavern (probably made by you?) was correctly placed, (despite being without much content) as it is not a very serious thing.

To make a section of something - clever like that, would be like making an extra section for the AMW for "masterpieces" in my opinion. Neither happens often, and the cleverness/masterpieciousity is often selective to the thread-creator.
DaoGao
offline
DaoGao
220 posts
Nomad

What is all this unnecessary attack on me? I just made a suggestion on the Help and Suggestion forum. Jeez.

idontsuckthatmuch
offline
idontsuckthatmuch
2,261 posts
Nomad

I don't really think it's necessary. That's what the Tavern is for. I personally don't think we need another category. It is pretty broad.

Cenere
offline
Cenere
13,657 posts
Jester

What is all this unnecessary attack on me? I just made a suggestion on the Help and Suggestion forum. Jeez.

I fail to see anyone attacking you.

Anyway, as mentioned, currently there seem little use in this, and I assume the staff agrees, as there have been a good number of suggestions for new sections in this genre, and none of them have been made.
Depending on how the AG3 forums will be, I am sure the mods and staff could end up discussing the different aspects of the forum and what content we wish to place where, and new sections might develop, but that is out in the future somewhere after the new site has been launched and so on.
Showing 1-10 of 10