ForumsWEPRWas Easter really on a Sunday?

15 3967
MoonFairy
offline
MoonFairy
3,386 posts
Shepherd

Easter on Wednesday?
What do you think about it? Wednesday or Sunday?

  • 15 Replies
qwerty1011
offline
qwerty1011
554 posts
Peasant

I don't know and it doesn't really matter since that date has no real significance anyway

Researchers have long been puzzled by an apparent inconsistency in the Bible.
While Matthew, Mark and Luke all say the Last Supper coincided with the start of the Jewish festival of Passover, John claims it took place before Passover.


I can't believe people evn care abut inconsistencies in the bible anymore since there are tonnes and even more bits which are obivously not true
MoonFairy
offline
MoonFairy
3,386 posts
Shepherd

I can't believe people evn care abut inconsistencies in the bible anymore since there are tonnes and even more bits which are obivously not true

Well, the Bible is more of a self interpretation, and no one has stuck around long enough from those times to tell us what really happened.
darver
offline
darver
189 posts
Nomad

Well there's no evidence claiming that Easter wasn't on a Thursday or Tuesday.

Researchers have long been puzzled by an apparent inconsistency in the Bible.
While Matthew, Mark and Luke all say the Last Supper coincided with the start of the Jewish festival of Passover, John claims it took place before Passover.


Well the majority is against John.
MoonFairy
offline
MoonFairy
3,386 posts
Shepherd

Did you even look at the link, Darver?

Divisible
offline
Divisible
104 posts
Nomad

I'm a bit puzzled about that, if they went by different calenders would that mean separate people thought it was a different day? Well, I suppose that is irrelevant to this thread.

To be honest, I'm not really sure what to believe, it just depends on which calender you're more faithful in I guess, even if Easter was on a Wednesday not much people are actually going to stop celebrating it on a Sunday and start doing so on a Wednesday, but I'll say it's an interesting theory, I'll look at some more articles later.

darkxrainx
offline
darkxrainx
25 posts
Nomad

It's just the day we choose to commemorate his death. All I know personally is that Jesus died (Good Friday, the Friday before Easter) and three days later, he arose. We just choose to commemorate it on the Friday as his death and the Sunday as his arisal... or however you would change arose.

darkxrainx
offline
darkxrainx
25 posts
Nomad

Easter Sunday is the first Sunday after the first full moon after vernal equinox. (vernal meaning Spring I believe....)

I read this and thought this might have also been the answer you were looking for..

314d1
offline
314d1
3,817 posts
Nomad

It's just the day we choose to commemorate his death. All I know personally is that Jesus died (Good Friday, the Friday before Easter) and three days later, he arose.


Then you know nothing.

It is one of the inconsistencies, it is likely to never have historically happened. Since it is likely to never have historically happened, it was probably functional to put it on a Sabbath as that day was already considered holly, so they just when for it.
darkxrainx
offline
darkxrainx
25 posts
Nomad

Then you know nothing.


Correction. All I believe. How's that? Anyway, they probably did put commemorate it on a Sunday because it is a holy day.
Ernie15
offline
Ernie15
13,344 posts
Bard

Well the majority is against John.


That's true, 3 against 1. John is legally wrong.

All I know personally is that Jesus died (Good Friday, the Friday before Easter) and three days later, he arose.


That would mean Easter should be on a Monday.
darkxrainx
offline
darkxrainx
25 posts
Nomad

That would mean Easter should be on a Monday


I'm not for sure he died on a Friday. I don't know why I claimed that. Anyway, I asked my mom and she said it had something to do with Passover. That's her opinion.
regenouis
offline
regenouis
30 posts
Peasant

The big thing that is being forgotten here is that it was never a secret that Easter, and Christmas aren't on the dates that we celebrate. Really, seriously, basic research brings this up. Even the Church does not deny that these holidays are based on Pagan holidays.

http://www.lightplanet.com/mormons/daily/holidays/celebrate_christmas.html

The reason we celebrate them on the days that we celebrate them is because King James decided he wanted to do a massive conversion to Christianity at a time when most of his kingdom still followed Pagan rituals. One of the MANY things he did in his...crusade if you will, was to decide that certain holidays would coincide with Pagan holidays to help the conversion process go a little smoother.

vesperbot
offline
vesperbot
955 posts
Nomad

The big thing that is being forgotten here is that it was never a secret that Easter, and Christmas aren't on the dates that we celebrate. Really, seriously, basic research brings this up. Even the Church does not deny that these holidays are based on Pagan holidays.
Fallacy of extrapolation. Christmas is indeed set as a fixed date of former pagan holiday, while Easter is set by the dating of the day of Jewish Pesakh, 14th Nisan of a particular year, calculated by a complicated formulae. Why the Easter is Sunday - it's said "Jesus resurrected on the third day after his death", and Jewish counted days starting with the present day, so tomorrow will be "the second day". Because Jesus died on the cross on the very day of his crucifixion, and other culprits were forced to die by breaking their legs because the evening of Pesakh was approaching, that day was definitely Friday. The third day was also marked in the Bible as "first day of the week", and their week ended with Saturday being sacrosanct day for Jewish. So it was a definite Sunday.

Mormons quote disregarded.
Kyouzou
offline
Kyouzou
5,061 posts
Jester

Christmas is set during the Roman holiday of Saturnalia if I remember my Latin correctly. It took place no only because it would make the conversion process more smooth, but Christianity couldn't deal with the fact that a sect they were trying to wipe out was having such a celebration, in return they decided let's just hijack it, it'll increase our popularity.

valkery
offline
valkery
1,255 posts
Nomad

Meh, Easter is based on the Pagan festival of Estar. When Christianity was introduced to the Romans, they had to put some of the Pagan worships into the belief system, just so it would go down easier.


Ignore the fisrt paragraph. The third one is the best.

Also, Christians have no idea when Jesus was born.

This link supplies some information of theories about his birthday

Showing 1-15 of 15