I preferred their old songs. I used to listen to them a lot, but sort of lost interest after Minutes to Midnight. I haven't heard all of the songs on their new albums, but the ones I have heard were awful in my opinion. Really, really awful.
well if this thread was posted when i used to listen to them (hate the band now theyre boring imo), id have to say old it had more substance to it, even though i think neither have much of anything but a bunch of sad sob stories now.