Yes she is. Basically they have tried to push her as punk, cause apparently Punk is the new in thing, and it failed miserably. All she is, is elevator alternative at the most extreme.
she was good and different in 2002. She was 17 then and should have not been a tomboy for as long as she was, which was just to sell her image to young kids. She should not have lasted past 2006 at the latest.