AGS Steam Games

Forums → Support Forum → Can we please do Reviews for games?

12 2262
WeegeeLord
offline
WeegeeLord
4 posts
Nomad

If we can, where do we go?

  • 12 Replies
GhostOfMatrix
offline
GhostOfMatrix
15,595 posts
Herald

You can post a review of the game in the comments section of the game.

PrincessofDaisies
offline
PrincessofDaisies
33 posts
Nomad

Comments seem more like a really slow chat to me. It can be cumbersome to locate quality posts for a popular game. Then again, if a game is popular are you want to post a lengthy review, most of it probably has been covered =P

acmed
offline
acmed
3,517 posts
Nomad

Comments seem more like a really slow chat to me.


You don't chat in comments, you comment in comments. If you chat, you banned
WeegeeLord
offline
WeegeeLord
4 posts
Nomad

I think that there should be a Review part of the Forums.

Still. :P

GhostOfMatrix
offline
GhostOfMatrix
15,595 posts
Herald

Game Reviews Forum.
There's a thread that discusses it, it was suggested for AG3. An administrator(cormyn) posted on the second page about it.

gaboloth
offline
gaboloth
1,612 posts
Peasant

I've always thought that the comment section should be divided in sections. If you look to kongregate (they already have the comment voting we'll have in ag3) the best rated comments are not good reviews, but little walkthroughs or tricks, and funny comments.
So I think having a section for comments and one for reviews would be great. And personally I would also like a "game discussion" section there, since in some games (like colony) people have been using comments for that for a long time, and the result was nice.

WeegeeLord
offline
WeegeeLord
4 posts
Nomad

Also, like Kongregate, we should have points and xp.

brp47
offline
brp47
580 posts
Peasant

You don't chat in comments, you comment in comments. If you chat, you banned


no u wont get banned u will be warned and have points taken off u
Also, like Kongregate, we should have points and xp.

we do..... armorpoints are on your profile page

>forum post = 1ap
>comments = 2ap
>rating = 2ap
>submitting a game = 20ap
>merit = 25ap
Jefferysinspiration
offline
Jefferysinspiration
3,139 posts
Farmer

The sections idea from kongregate is a good idea, but as it's been sad, the comment section on games are for revews/walkthroughs/tips.

zizo90
offline
zizo90
244 posts
Jester

i want to review the games
it need to have upgrade =)

GhostOfMatrix
offline
GhostOfMatrix
15,595 posts
Herald

I've always thought that the comment section should be divided in sections. If you look to kongregate (they already have the comment voting we'll have in ag3) the best rated comments are not good reviews, but little walkthroughs or tricks, and funny comments.
So I think having a section for comments and one for reviews would be great. And personally I would also like a "game discussion" section there, since in some games (like colony) people have been using comments for that for a long time, and the result was nice.

So with this, you mean having separated sections on games? Do you also mean having a tab on game comments for threads about that game?
If so, then I'd like that idea. It would be more organized.
Also, like Kongregate, we should have points and xp.

There are points on ArmorGames. If you go to your profile then scroll down you will see them. However, in AG3 the points scheme will be different. There are threads in the AG3 sub-forum if you'd like more information.
i want to review the games

Go right ahead. Leave your reviews in the comments sections of the games.
ShardRaldevius
offline
ShardRaldevius
107 posts
Nomad

Comments seem more like a really slow chat to me. It can be cumbersome to locate quality posts for a popular game. Then again, if a game is popular are you want to post a lengthy review, most of it probably has been covered =P

Thats why we have admins doing cleanups and flags to report bad users
Showing 1-12 of 12