I would have to choose Move after my experience with both.
I played some Kinect games with a friend and the only game I feel fun is the sports game, can't remember the name though. It's nice to play without any controllers but I feel like the Kinect inaccurate. Or maybe it's "too accurate". For example in bowling, just to pick up a bowl you need to put your hand on a specific point for some seconds.
Move would just require a sweeping gesture on that spot to get the bowl and start bowling. In a sense the Move is just more accurate or "nicer to play with". I also feel like the controller that the Move has is is better than you being the controller. It just feels like you're missing something when playing with Kinect. The games the Move feature are better than the games in Kinect's library.
I'd rather not have people thinking that I talk to myself while playing video games, d_dude. Kinect isn't that responsive for me, and I like holding a controller rather than jumping around in the air in-front of the screen.
Kinect has voice functions. So Kinect wins. I don't think Move has voice commands. I can't wait to play ME3 with Kinect.
When the Wii uses motion instead of the usual button input people cry foul but when Kinect does the same with voice control, everyone goes ZOMG INNOVASHUN.
Double Standards everywhere (and not just this board specifically)T_T
I can't say I care for any of the two, but it seems Sony is being much smarter on how they market it. I don't see Sony shoving Move in everyones face unlike this other company. Microsoft still thinks people will buy that just because it has motion controls (instead of, you know, good games). Sony seems more focused on including Move with games that are actually targeted towards their core audience.
The Wii was groundbreaking with the motion control, but the Kinect is revolutionary. Now there is no controller needed at all and you are the controller. PS3 move, bacicly and exact copy of the will but the handels have glowing balls on top.
If you're going with what motion control was first, than they both stole from Sony with the Playstation Eye, especially Kinect.
Folks, if you really have to start a fanboy flamewar over "WHO STOLE THEM MOTION CONTROLS", atleast get your facts straight.
The Wii was groundbreaking with the motion control, but the Kinect is revolutionary. Now there is no controller needed at all and you are the controller. PS3 move, bacicly and exact copy of the will but the handels have glowing balls on top.
Inb4 Eyetoy. Also how is that revolutionary? Just having a new piece of technology is worth nothing if you make crap games for DA CASHUALZ and all the other studios don't use the tech (and instead just replace button inputs with voice commands).
