My copy of Fallout 3 has a perfect circle scratch. To make matters worse, I own all the DLC. I also own Assasins Creed II, and have one achievement left before I have all the achievements.
So the plan is for me to go to Gamestop, and offer Assasins Creed II for Fallout 3. AC2 has a pre-owned value of 14.99, and Fallout 3 has a pre-owned value of 7.99.
As ACII works perfectly, is there any reason why they wouldn't let me make the trade? I went to Gamestop's website, but they didn't have much information on making trades.
I don't think there should be any reason they would not let you trade games. Remember though that you will not get 14.99 out of AC2 because they have to make money off of you.