ForumsPopular MediaGuitar VS Bass

21 6804
macfan1
offline
macfan1
421 posts
Nomad

What is better? I can't decide whether to buy a bass($200) or guitar($179). (guitar is understood as electric) So what do you think?

  • 21 Replies
TheGr8est
offline
TheGr8est
703 posts
Nomad

I think that guitars are better and cooler, but if your looking for something a little more original, go wuth the bass.

COD6
offline
COD6
28 posts
Peasant

guitar it gives you the real rock n roll feelin and its cheaper so....

COD6
offline
COD6
28 posts
Peasant

guitar it gives you the real rock n roll feelin and its cheaper so....

delossantosj
offline
delossantosj
6,672 posts
Nomad

BUY A BASS!!!!!! there are NOT enough bass players in the world. it is SO GOD DANG HARD to find a bassist for a band. i know. i was in a band recording tracks in the studio and everything and we didnt have a bassist, we just randomly made a bass track for our songs, who knows how good those songs would have sounded with a sick bassline.

Ernie15
offline
Ernie15
13,344 posts
Bard

there are NOT enough bass players in the world.


The way I see it, there are just too many guitarists in the world. If you can play both, people will ultimately be more impressed if you can play the one more people cannot play.
KhaoticSniper
offline
KhaoticSniper
210 posts
Nomad

The way I see it, there are just too many guitarists in the world. If you can play both, people will ultimately be more impressed if you can play the one more people cannot play.


Agreed!!! thats why i am trying to learn Bass too, Cause i already play the Guitar.
Skeleton_Pilot
offline
Skeleton_Pilot
1,361 posts
Blacksmith

It really all depends on what you plan on doing after you've purchased your instrument!

Having that said... what do you plan on doing after you've purchased your instrument?

KhaoticSniper
offline
KhaoticSniper
210 posts
Nomad

Having that said... what do you plan on doing after you've purchased your instrument?


Well I'm in a Band so what do u think I'm gonna do. :P
ihsahn
offline
ihsahn
428 posts
Nomad

I took up bass because I could kick a tree and five guitarists would fall out. Seemed more original and easier to find a band.

There's no such thing as "a" bass or guitar, though. They're not like apples or staplers. Guitars have a single price tag. Giving us one price for the generic concept of the instrument, like it doesn't matter what exact bass or guitar you're buying, is naive at best.

You want to look into buying something that plays well and has good value, because buying a bad instrument will turn you off of even wanting to play at all. What bass and guitar are we talking about?

ihsahn
offline
ihsahn
428 posts
Nomad

Guitars don't* have a single price tag, I meant. Ugh. This forum needs an edit function, at least for a limited time after you post.

Kaidou16
offline
Kaidou16
20 posts
Nomad

I've been playing bass since I was 13. The chords are easier to remember than Csusmaj7 or whatever that is. And with a bass, you can play without using a pick. I think it sounds better without a pick. I'd suggest definitely going with bass.

ihsahn
offline
ihsahn
428 posts
Nomad

I've been playing bass since I was 13. The chords are easier to remember than Csusmaj7 or whatever that is. And with a bass, you can play without using a pick. I think it sounds better without a pick. I'd suggest definitely going with bass.

But that is kind of a lazy way to pick an instrument, though, isn't it? You should have a little more passion. Bass is easier to pick up, but just as difficult to master. Think like that and you'll be well on your way to being a mediocre bassist.

You end up having to know the chord and scale shapes anyway if you want to do anything but follow the guitars mindlessly, throw a fill here and there, be able to solo and write your own bass lines competently. And also if you want to compose full songs - especially because bass is a terrible instrument to write on, if you're anything like me, in which case you'll want to know some guitar or piano for that.
I had to develop a rudimentary ability on the keyboard purely out of a need to study theory on something that could play real chords.
delossantosj
offline
delossantosj
6,672 posts
Nomad

you can play without using a pick with a regular guitar too.

but if you are in a band, than bass is the way to go.

MrDayCee
offline
MrDayCee
14,745 posts
King

Definitely a guitar! Much more versatile instrument than a bass! =)

And even though there are more than on guitaristas out there... just try to be different and fresh! Be awesome! =D

JoshTheBoss
offline
JoshTheBoss
417 posts
Nomad

No instrument is best. Buy an instrument that you wanna play, not one that someone told you to buy.

Showing 1-15 of 21