ForumsWEPRShould Pornography Be Illegal?

66 11268
coldplaya
offline
coldplaya
355 posts
Nomad

Write your thoughts on this lively debate and see who's opinion comes out on top!


I Personally Think Yes, but if you have a different opinion please Respond!

  • 66 Replies
Moegreche
offline
Moegreche
3,826 posts
Duke

First, even if it should, this is something that would be impossible to enforce. In fact, I think it would be impossible to even legislate. How exactly do we define pornography?
Is it based on the intention of the producer or the use of the consumer? If it's based on the intentions of the producer, then what's to keep someone from just saying that a picture is art? The porn industry has actually made a shift in the past 5 or so years to become more "artsy" - whatever that means.
If it's going to be defined based on use, then a painting like Birth of Venus could potentially be considered pornographic if someone wants "get off" to it.

Also, it would seem that if something is already legal, we would need to give an argument for why it should be made illegal. This is a huge industry with billions of dollars at stake. We can't illegalize it on a whim.

It should be up to the opponents of pornography to provide a cogent argument for making it illegal. Otherwise, why on earth would anyone listen?

deserteagle
offline
deserteagle
1,633 posts
Nomad

This is a huge industry with billions of dollars at stake.


Exactly. Porn is a very profitable business. Major Industries that make billions tend to be hard to close.

If people want to dance scantily clad in front of a camera, they should be entitled to do so. It doesn't directly harm any one.
Zophia
offline
Zophia
9,434 posts
Scribe

Look what I found.

I... Don't even know what to with this thread... The old one appears to have been locked purely because it was necro'd. I could possibly unlock it for continued discussion, but I guess we might as well have it running all over again.

RugRat
offline
RugRat
340 posts
Nomad

Stay away from my porn!!!!!


Also you wouldn't stop porn by making it illegal, there is no way to stop the constant stream of fap fodder being uploaded every second on the internet and women's magazines would see a sharp rise in profits the day after the law is passed (if we are only talking about guys)

NoNameC68
offline
NoNameC68
5,043 posts
Shepherd

I agree. Pornography should be illegal because it is immoral and God looks down upon such terrible habit. Those are facts. When a person watches porn, they feel the need to want it, which makes them have sex with people they would normally have waited for. Because they didn't wait, they couldn't stay in a relationship with that person, which results in them feeling sad and they feel like the only thing to make up for what happened is for them to have more sex. They have sex with more people and because they decided not to wait, again, they break up and become even more depressed. Pornography also makes people gay. Either guys get tired of looking at women and decide to become gay, or the guy sees a penis and decides to become gay. I don't know which one of the two, whichever sounds better. Pornography makes people want to have sex with animals. If it didn't, then why is there porn of it? Also, my mom caught me masturbating... stupid porn.

deserteagle
offline
deserteagle
1,633 posts
Nomad

I agree. Pornography should be illegal because it is immoral and God looks down upon such terrible habit. Those are facts. When a person watches porn, they feel the need to want it, which makes them have sex with people they would normally have waited for. Because they didn't wait, they couldn't stay in a relationship with that person, which results in them feeling sad and they feel like the only thing to make up for what happened is for them to have more sex. They have sex with more people and because they decided not to wait, again, they break up and become even more depressed. Pornography also makes people gay. Either guys get tired of looking at women and decide to become gay, or the guy sees a penis and decides to become gay. I don't know which one of the two, whichever sounds better. Pornography makes people want to have sex with animals. If it didn't, then why is there porn of it? Also, my mom caught me masturbating... stupid porn.


Nice sarcasm NoName! I got a laugh out of it...
pHacon
offline
pHacon
1,903 posts
Nomad

Lawls ^
Porn, well, where should I start...
First amendment protects it here, and there would probably be riots if it was all deleted all of the sudden, but really, it would be hard, if not impossible to actually ban something like porn, especially with the internet.

I particularly think the world would be better without a distraction like that, especially one that takes potentially useful people and dulls their minds like so.

Ernie15
offline
Ernie15
13,344 posts
Bard

I don't know why it's illegal. What laws does it break? It has no reason to be illegal!

All I want are answers.

Xzeno
offline
Xzeno
2,301 posts
Nomad

I didn't know mods were allowed to troll.

Pornography is free speech, so it shouldn't be illegal. It may be a distasteful type of free speech, but it is pretty tame (and mostly harmless) as far as distasteful speech goes.

I don't know why it's illegal. What laws does it break? It has no reason to be illegal!
Where is it illegal?
pHacon
offline
pHacon
1,903 posts
Nomad

I don't know why it's illegal. What laws does it break? It has no reason to be illegal!

Ernie... It isn't illegal...
All I want are answers.

I'm sure. :P
Ernie15
offline
Ernie15
13,344 posts
Bard

Ernie... It isn't illegal...


Phew, that's a relief--I mean, that's fine.

In that case...

I Personally Think Yes


Why?
Moegreche
offline
Moegreche
3,826 posts
Duke

Again, until we get a clearer definition of &quotornography" I think the discussion is moot. I don't see a definition that will capture all instances of what we intuitively think of as pornography while excluding intuitively non-pornographic material.

I mean, really whether or not porn should be illegal is a trivial discussion. Of course it shouldn't. As someone already pointed out, it is a clear violation of the First Amendment.
I think a far more interesting discussion is to try and define pornography.

RugRat
offline
RugRat
340 posts
Nomad

can't seem to find the robot chicken vid with people rioting after a new virus started deleting porn on hard drives and the internet.............rioting ensued

pHacon
offline
pHacon
1,903 posts
Nomad

can't seem to find the robot chicken vid with people rioting after a new virus started deleting porn on hard drives and the internet.............rioting ensued


That actually happened? I thought it was a myth!

mean, really whether or not porn should be illegal is a trivial discussion. Of course it shouldn't. As someone already pointed out, it is a clear violation of the First Amendment.
I think a far more interesting discussion is to try and define pornography.

Is this good?

1. Sexually explicit pictures, writing, or other material whose primary purpose is to cause sexual arousal.

2. The presentation or production of this material.

3. Lurid or sensational material
RugRat
offline
RugRat
340 posts
Nomad

Nah, it didn't actually happen, Robot Chicken is a sketch comedy show that uses dolls. All I can make up of it is that the episode is number 25 of season 2 and it's the last sketch of the show titles :
Omaha's number 1 news team

Showing 1-15 of 66