I think that we should use illegal immigrants in the US army. I mean, they just come into our country and take jobs away from americans. I dont think thats right. what do you think?
This is unclear, it says mexicans, and by Mexicans I'm guessing you mean illeagal immigrants? Or do you... Well, mexicans can join the military already so that doesnt make any sense...
This is clearly a ridiculous idea. Ethical issues aside many of them wouldnt be able to speak english and so wouldnt be able to take orders or learn anything for a start.
This is clearly a ridiculous idea. Ethical issues aside many of them wouldnt be able to speak english and so wouldnt be able to take orders or learn anything for a start.
Then we would get camanders who could our world changes we need to adapt or die. That or we deport them which just seems like such a waste.
Then we would get camanders who could our world changes we need to adapt or die. That or we deport them which just seems like such a waste.
First of all its spelt commanders. Secondly that first sentence doesnt even make sense. Thirdly you talk about deporting and them being a waste as if they are the property of the US government to do with as they please. Just because they have entered the US illegally doesnt mean the US can shove them in the army, they still have basic human rights. Im sure many US citizens wouldnt like illegal immigrants in the army either.
This is a racist thread. You should be saying ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS not "Mexicans". Most Mexicans, actually, are legal. If you talk to some, you would realize that. Your just ignorant.
Says illegal on the first post. Also i know my best friends dad can here lealy when he was 14 im not stupid i know most are legal get back on topic :P
First of all its spelt commanders. Secondly that first sentence doesnt even make sense. Thirdly you talk about deporting and them being a waste as if they are the property of the US government to do with as they please. Just because they have entered the US illegally doesnt mean the US can shove them in the army, they still have basic human rights. Im sure many US citizens wouldnt like illegal immigrants in the army either.
firstly ok...?secondly "we should get commanders who can translate and work with them?thirdly as far as im concerened there drugs they entered here illegaly we can do what we want with them. Lastly i doubt you disagree we need a better easier system for imigration im sure most people would understand.
thirdly as far as im concerened there drugs they entered here illegaly
Why are you making the assumption that they are drug traffickers? Illegal immigrants are people who enter and live in a country illegally not drug smugglers.
we can do what we want with them
Simply not true. Forcing illegal immigrants to join the army is a serious breach of basic human rights. There are laws that exist preventing this kind of treatment to criminals.
Lastly i doubt you disagree we need a better easier system for imigration im sure most people would understand.
First of all i am NOT american (or indeed mexican) and so am not bias like many people i have seen on this thread. Secondly i do not see how putting people in the military would help immigration. One of many peoples biggest complainy about it is how much it ccosts the us economy to have people who use its services but dont pay taxes etc. Putting them in the army would raise the cost of having these people in the US. Thirdly most people in the US i am sure would be against this scheme.
First of all i am NOT american (or indeed mexican) and so am not bias like many people i have seen on this thread. Secondly i do not see how putting people in the military would help immigration. One of many peoples biggest complainy about it is how much it ccosts the us economy to have people who use its services but dont pay taxes etc. Putting them in the army would raise the cost of having these people in the US. Thirdly most people in the US i am sure would be against this scheme.
did u not read any other pages?this would be there choice completley, if we discovered they were illegal they could join. If they werent even in our country they could join. If they were illegal they could come and ask to be in the military. Also if you not american no offence but your opinion matter little to this thread im guessing you don't have boarder problems.
Why are you making the assumption that they are drug traffickers? Illegal immigrants are people who enter and live in a country illegally not drug smugglers.
-.- im not saying there traficars it was a metaphor.
this would be there choice completley, if we discovered they were illegal they could join.
There are restrictions on elligibility into the military, and being an illegal immigrant excudes you. This whole idea of joining the military to get in the US is simply ludicrous. Mnay of them go to such drastic measures to get into the US in the first place to escape extreme levels of poverty, and so even though they have a choice, many of them would still be very against joining the military. Practically forcing people to join an organisation in which they could get killed or face returning to a poverty stricken lifestyle is a horrible thing to force peole to do, especially if they have families.
Also if you not american no offence but your opinion matter little to this thread im guessing you don't have boarder problems.
I am a British citizen , a second generation immigrant to the UK and i am currently serving in the Royal Air Force and so i do feel strongly about this. In addition the Uk does have many illegal immigrants aswell eg Polish, African, Middle Eastern, South American, there are more than you think. Even if i didnty come from a country with an illegal immigrant problem that doesnt mean i am not entitled to my opinion on this topic.
Illegal immigrantion is a legal matter that should be dealt with by the judiciary not the military.end of.
I am a British citizen , a second generation immigrant to the UK and i am currently serving in the Royal Air Force and so i do feel strongly about this. In addition the Uk does have many illegal immigrants aswell eg Polish, African, Middle Eastern, South American, there are more than you think. Even if i didnty come from a country with an illegal immigrant problem that doesnt mean i am not entitled to my opinion on this topic.
Illegal immigrantion is a legal matter that should be dealt with by the judiciary not the military.end of.
Ok i apoligise then that was ignorant of me. And i agree but well i think this is a judiciary way of handaling this.
There are restrictions on elligibility into the military, and being an illegal immigrant excudes you. This whole idea of joining the military to get in the US is simply ludicrous. Mnay of them go to such drastic measures to get into the US in the first place to escape extreme levels of poverty, and so even though they have a choice, many of them would still be very against joining the military. Practically forcing people to join an organisation in which they could get killed or face returning to a poverty stricken lifestyle is a horrible thing to force peole to do, especially if they have families.
