Forums → Popular Media → Battle of the Movies

Sherlock Holmes wins. There was no competition.

Sherlock Holmes- 0
Alice in Wonderland- 0

I am going to make an Ag Movies Awards thread, and use all of the top movies from this thread.

I really didn't like the new version of Alice in Wonderland. I did, however, find Sherlock Holmes to be quite entertaining, and that is the one I shall vote for.

I saw nether movie so im going with sherlock holmes

Sherlock Holmes.
That was the pretty much the only time I've enjoyed a movie more than a book. The Alice one (book not movie) was a little morbid...

I would have to agree with pHacon, the book drags along and is unintersting, but the movie is exciting, whitty, and intense. As for Alice, Ihate fantasy movies. My vote goes to Sherlock Holmes.

Tim Burton is a very, very strange man, so my vote is for Alice.

Sherlock Holmes is better because The Alice movie had a poor start while Holmes was good start to finish.

I'm goign with Holmes simply becasue I like real time movies better than animation

Sherlock Holmes Because alice was confusing and a lot of things were happening all at once.

are we going to vote for classic movies like Waynes's World?

I vote Sherlock Holmes its a good film but Alice in wonderland is just weird.

Easily Alice In Wonderland for me. Johnny Depp just makes awesome movies. So unless it's Depp vs. Depp, I'll always lean towards his movie vs. anyone else's.

Sherlock Holmes was definently better then alice in wonderland.

Alice in wonderland
maybe it differs a bit from the book,but it is still cool

Sherlock Holmes, Alice In Wonderland was just plain out stupid in my opinion. I hate movies that are "Cartoon-ish", so my vote will go for Sherlock Holmes.