ForumsWEPRIf a Tree fell in the Forest...

88 19402
afroninja1723
offline
afroninja1723
575 posts
Nomad

If a tree fell in the forest and no one was around to hear it would it make a sound?

Personally I think not, If there is no one to hear the sound, there is only a vibration in the air, and that this does not constitute sound.

I want to know your opinions of this age old myth.

  • 88 Replies
JimmyMacX
offline
JimmyMacX
21 posts
Nomad

There's always someone or in most cases something around to hear it but even if there weren't it would still make a sound.

XXAlienGirlXX
offline
XXAlienGirlXX
810 posts
Nomad

Dominos FTW... :P

Sporemaniac777
offline
Sporemaniac777
1,373 posts
Nomad

It would make a sound... duh... The sound is always there even if nobody hears it.

Llamasushi
offline
Llamasushi
102 posts
Peasant

Wait a sec...what about that theory that when a butterfly flaps it's wings in America, say, then there'll be a hurricane in Japan? It's like, the effect expands over a larger area...the dominoes effect? Idno...forgot the name of it O.o

But the same could be said for the vibrations in the air, right? So if the tree fell, the vibrations could carry and eventually be added to the multitude of other sounds in the world, and eventually someone would hear it, but they won't know that it was from a tree. Right? So technically, someone would hear the sound, they just wouldn't know that it was from a tree. Lol :/

IfYouInsist
offline
IfYouInsist
259 posts
Nomad

Although there is no proof or anyone to hear it, yes it would make sound.

zakyman
offline
zakyman
1,627 posts
Peasant

DONT NECRO > !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

ianhq
offline
ianhq
150 posts
Nomad

It doesn't make a sound. If there isnt a person it doesnt matter.

Mistersadman
offline
Mistersadman
26 posts
Nomad

It does make a sound.

Foraker
offline
Foraker
100 posts
Nomad

Theoretical it does make a sound.
I like the theory with the butterfly effect.
The vibration in the air starts a chain reaction.
So it doesn't matter if someone heard it or not.
Depends on the definition of the word ''sound''.

Proxator
offline
Proxator
6 posts
Nomad

Sound takes time to travel through space, but eventually the wave would dissapate into white noise (a frequency that our human ears cannont tune too)

master565
offline
master565
4,104 posts
Nomad

I can't actually believe anyone thinks the tree will make no sense, anyone who does is just being the Devil's advocate.

StDrake
offline
StDrake
194 posts
Lord

Going by the butterfly effect it seems that even with a negative interpretation it still makes a sound - even if noone is around, where there are trees there are surely creatures capable of interpreting air vibrations as a sound within sufficiently large distance, though after such a distance it may become too quiet for them to perceive it. Still - it reaches them

Sparkytrick1
offline
Sparkytrick1
100 posts
Nomad

It makes vibrations, and thus sound. Also, something's bound to hear it.

Showing 76-88 of 88