Let us take it like this: If you make a proper thread with good material, then no. Is the thread filled with nonsense, has it been discussed a thousand times, and thus is simply a repeat, or is it filled with spam, flames and trolling, yes.
It was not a Nazi thread, it was a thread questioning whether Nazis are bad or not, and as far as I know, that will lead to a bunch of problems, especially from people supporting your view, when they are criticized.
As far as I know, that happened far back, while the Nazis tried to do so only 50 years back. Christians did it because they wanted to save people from going to hell, sadly slaughtering the "non believers" which is nothing to be proud of, while the Nazis decided Aryans was the superior race, and therefor everyone else should die, this happening with a fuhrer that was short, had dark hair, and was in family with what he hated the most, Jews. At least the Christians actually was Christians.