ForumsSupport ForumNew System for Rating Games (5 Numbers)

19 3947
sinopoli32
offline
sinopoli32
181 posts
Nomad

I always put 5 numbers in my comments as my ratings
#####

#1:Overall
#2ifficulty (do u like the difficulty)
#3:Playability (Is it easy to learn)
#4:Concept (obvious what this means)
#5:Length

I usually average the last 4 for the first

Why cant we get the other 4 bars to see what others think of the game's difficulty, playability, etc...

  • 19 Replies
Graham
offline
Graham
8,047 posts
Nomad

even if that was implemented it'd still be abused by selecting seven 5 times

is it really that bigof deal to know? it's fine if you wanna be pedantic in your reviews but i'd stick with 1 rating system for its easyness

ramzaman
offline
ramzaman
231 posts
Farmer

that is a pretty good system

Pixie214
offline
Pixie214
5,837 posts
Peasant

I see people doing it in FOG in the commesnt box but all they qrite is

D-5
P-5
C-5
L-5

And it looks terrible.

I think it would be interesting but what would the AP be like. You get 2 points for all of them or 2 for each?

Green12324
offline
Green12324
4,097 posts
Peasant

I like that idea, then the developers would be able to know what they need to improve on. As for the AP, there could be the normal overall rating that you get two points for, and then once you vote on that a drop down menu comes out asking for your specific ratings that you wouldn't get AP for.

sinopoli32
offline
sinopoli32
181 posts
Nomad

You would get 2 points for filling out all 5 together at one time

goumas13
offline
goumas13
4,749 posts
Grand Duke

It's not bad, it's a quite good suggestion, it can be helpful and it may also reduce the mass ratings. Good idea.

Ernie15
offline
Ernie15
13,344 posts
Bard

once you vote on that a drop down menu comes out asking for your specific ratings that you wouldn't get AP for.


But 90% of users will ignore that...
sinopoli32
offline
sinopoli32
181 posts
Nomad

can we get a mod to look at this idea?

goumas13
offline
goumas13
4,749 posts
Grand Duke

can we get a mod to look at this idea?

Don't worry mods look the support and suggestion forum very often, when a mod will be on he will probably notice your thread.
sinopoli32
offline
sinopoli32
181 posts
Nomad

okay
ill wait

sinopoli32
offline
sinopoli32
181 posts
Nomad

if a mod sees this can they tell me what they think on my comments

Green12324
offline
Green12324
4,097 posts
Peasant

But 90% of users will ignore that...


But the ones that do notice it would give honest ratings, instead of just giving a rating because they want points.
silentclore
offline
silentclore
297 posts
Nomad

If your writing those 5 things you might as well put a little bit more effort and make a merit worthy comment. Some people just don't want to write a tad lengthy comment they just want to say "good game" or "boring".

Freakenstein
offline
Freakenstein
9,503 posts
Jester

People get points for just clicking a button? Wth?? I like how a more-specific rating system would define a game to a fuller extent, but people should NOT get points for rating it. Defeats the purpose of showing how good/bad the game is; the games would have a more legit rating given if people weren't given an incentive to rating it, because, like people have already said, they wouldn't give 2 cares.

sinopoli32
offline
sinopoli32
181 posts
Nomad

the good people who are willing to rate for no Ap will rate fairly so we will have fair ratings on the more detailed parts

Showing 1-15 of 19