To my surprise, this turn out to be a tier 5 magic tutor, although I have all fame and repute max out along with both combat and magic abilities. Max sins is not too avoidable (due to high advanture required to earn money as the quickest path) but I expect max compassion and moral could balance it out, which turn out to be not the case.
I had made another tier 3 holy paladin, that doesn't have max magic abilites, repute and fame. Only have combat abilities and repute. It also have max sin, however has max amount of faith.
Did anybody achieved tier 1 or tier 2 and what are the requirements?
I tried changing around my equipment, getting the ending and reloading but it didn't affect the score, I tried it with my protector gear, a set of mastery and random junk in my inventory.
What did change it was where I chose to rest during the last week. Forest gave me the least amount of points, beach gave a little more, but going into town gave the most points during the last week. When I tried to stay at home, I ended up with less then forest, it also dropped me down from tier 2 to tier 4 because my refinement wasn't maxxed.
I've played this game quite a bit since it came out and I've gotten the completely unknown ending despite good stats too. I think it really depends on what you max out your career as, like I tried it with just maxing out construction and end up completely unknown. If I play the exact same way and instead max out stablehand I get noble knight.
Since the game has been compared to PM2 so much it makes me think it might be irritating set of stat requirements to get protector general. Something like your refinement has to be between 50-80 and humility between 60-90, and if you go over the stats you end up tier 2. Or maybe tier 1 and mastering dragon taming hasn't been implemented yet :P
after reading this i decided to hack with artmoney and see if i could get tier 1, unfortunatly i used pet protector 2 so may not be up to date, here are the results
every stat 1000, every job 100, every dungeon completed, every weapon/clothing supreme godlike,