ForumsGamesFlawed IGN review ratings

54 5200
tomthesniper
offline
tomthesniper
309 posts
Nomad

Everyone knows IGN is in it for the money, and rates games as such. Name a game that they totally failed at reviewing, and give the rating you think it ACTUALLY earned.
Example:
Darkest of Days
IGN score: 4/10
My score: 7/10
I give this score since I beleive the game wasn't terrible. Sure it had some flaws, but the game was solid and IGN was way too harsh in their review, mostly because their BIASED and CORRUPT. But who isn't these days right?

# Please do not criticize my review of the game. Keep those opinions to yourself, but feel free to wine all you want about IGN.

  • 54 Replies
tomthesniper
offline
tomthesniper
309 posts
Nomad

What the world needs now is not a yes man, but someone willing to go against the demographic to succeed. I do enjoy how everyone shares my spite. However, can we please stay on topic. Just because Klaus ruins everything else in his life, does not mean he should ruin a thread about a perfectly decent subject. Now, let's share some opinions, shall we?

GamesArmor
offline
GamesArmor
890 posts
Nomad

I wouldn't agree with IGN's score, but not yours either. Some of the bugs and the poor graphics took away some of the games experience, and the storyline was kinda confusing...

I would give it a 5.5

But that's just me.

Klaushouse
offline
Klaushouse
2,770 posts
Nomad

1. They are the opinion of ONE PERSON, and it should not affect how you choose games

It's the opinion of one man who has played an accumulative of more games than the population of AG combined. And who was hired to make unbiased opinions towards games in a fashion that shows people what the game is about so that they can make their own decisions.
2. Most of the sponsors are paying to smear or support a game, and the reviewers do give scores as such

No they don't. That's what the entire gamespot scandal was about and they were called out on it. Companies who do that get in a ton of shit.

If you disagree with me screw you. I don't give a rat's *** about your opinion. I am tied to my convictions.

Ok. Then stop arguing? If you don't give a rat's ass then log off and never come back.


This guy is all over the place with these types of comments. It needs to stop.

Super cop here, protecting AG from one of it's most active users who just happens to be honest to little kids about their stupidity!

I'll fight fire with whatever the hell I want. Klaushouse is a ****, and I won't tolerate so long as I am a member of this site.

Firstly, he was trying to agree with you and say I deserved more than what I got. So you sortoff acted like a dick to the guy who agreed with you, good job champ. And secondly, you won't tolerate? Who the hell do you think you are, Martin Luther King? This is ArmorGames and I act like a jerk, get over yourself and just ignore me if you hate what I say.

Just because Klaus ruins everything else in his life

LOL? Thanks for the update on my life, I wasn't aware that me actually enjoying myself I am ruin it. You are the ones taking someone on the internet too seriously, so I want to ask: whose ruining their life, the guy enjoying himself being a jerk or the idiot who spends his life crying about it?
TheAntiHero412
offline
TheAntiHero412
165 posts
Nomad

internet fights ftw? woot for epic fail

Newbie055
offline
Newbie055
49 posts
Peasant

Off topic: Flame wars, woohoo. Someone should mod this thread before it gets out of hand.

On topic: Game reviews shouldn't be taken at face value. They're there to point things out, and ultimately it's up to the individual gamer to decide if they like a game or not. A game that gets poor ratings shouldn't snuff out all interest in that particular game.

tomthesniper
offline
tomthesniper
309 posts
Nomad

Klaus, shut the fuck up and go on to another thread. From the get go, you have to flame on my thread. Do you have anything else to do with your life other than making fun of kids? If you don't like me or my opinions, there is a whole website, and a whole world, in which you can distance yourself from me. Go to another thread, and stop flaming up mine, and you'll never need to hear any complaints from me again.

Hydraulic
offline
Hydraulic
223 posts
Nomad

Wow. A troll thread that turned into a flame war. Never seen that before. However... tomthesniper, everyone is entitled to their own opinion. If you don't like IGN's reviews, then keep it to yourself. And one more thing...

Go to another thread, and stop flaming up mine...

Seriously? You honestly expect me to believe that you didn't see a flame war coming?Think before you post, troll.
Klaushouse
offline
Klaushouse
2,770 posts
Nomad

Klaus, shut the **** up and go on to another thread. From the get go, you have to flame on my thread.

Hint hint. Your threads blow, stop making them.

Do you have anything else to do with your life other than making fun of kids?

No.

If you don't like me or my opinions, there is a whole website, and a whole world, in which you can distance yourself from me.

Hey. Lets edit that quote a little and see what it sounds like...
If you don't like IGN or their opinions, there is a whole website, and a whole world, in which you can distance yourself from them.

Wow! You're a stupid child hypocrite!

Go to another thread, and stop flaming up mine, and you'll never need to hear any complaints from me again.

Leave this website, and you will never need to hear from me again.
Elitemagical
offline
Elitemagical
1,207 posts
Nomad

I have to agree with Klaus. . . . The people whom have rated these games have been hired to do exactly that. They have played so many games that they excel to a massive company for games (like IGN) and can take in all the criteria a good game needs and judge what was accomplished in the game; these guys are not casual gamers. Blindly accusing them of giving a poor rating based on their opinion to whether the targets set to make a good game have been met is plain ignorant. Although these people are NOT perfect, they have been hired with pure expertise to represent what they thought of the game.

I do respect your opinion: I can understand that you feel a game was not rated as high as it should: sometimes I feel like that. In my opinion Unreal Tournament [99] should have been rated higher than it was, but these people are experts, and they have their own opinions, although I am not going to change my entire opinion based on theirs, I am not going to say their rating is completely wrong, flawed and required to be changed. To be quite frank their opinion is probably a lot more thoughtful than mine because they HAVE to look into every aspect of this game and see how good each individual part is to construct a complete rating for the game.

You have your opinion, they have theirs: they are trained, taught, given criteria, and have probably opened more install disk cases than you have seen.

tomthesniper
offline
tomthesniper
309 posts
Nomad

Yep Klaus. I'm often a hypocrite, and I am damn proud of it. The people that review these games are experts; I never questioned their experience with games. What I do question is their integrity with which they review it.

Now back to Klaus. How pitiful must your social life be if you spend your online time here making fun of the young. Wait hold on... I have really degraded myself to the point where I am arguing with some guy on the internet, trading points with him. Let's face it. Neither of us will see the end of it while this thread lasts. I want it to die, so I can move on to another, less flaming thread. Can all please give some closing statements then just stop posting on it. I am really getting tired of my own thread.

valkyrie1119
offline
valkyrie1119
1,720 posts
Nomad

Alright, here's what it boils down to. No one can win, so the arbiter, me, is going to step in and put down my decision.

First of all, Klaus, your a donkey's arse with your opinions.

Tom, you're awesome.

There, it's done.

tomthesniper
offline
tomthesniper
309 posts
Nomad

Thank you Valk. I can always rely on you.

Klaushouse
offline
Klaushouse
2,770 posts
Nomad

Now back to Klaus. How pitiful must your social life be if you spend your online time here making fun of the young.

Yep

Wait hold on... I have really degraded myself to the point where I am arguing with some guy on the internet,

I thought at this point I meant more to you than that?

trading points with him. Let's face it. Neither of us will see the end of it while this thread lasts.

Saying it like that makes it sound as if we are equal. Way to misinterpret your inferiority!

I want it to die, so I can move on to another, less flaming thread. Can all please give some closing statements then just stop posting on it. I am really getting tired of my own thread.

No, I like this thread. Cause I feel better each time you post stupid comments, makes me feel smarter. So I will do all I can to keep this alive until it's eventual demise into being locked.
tomthesniper
offline
tomthesniper
309 posts
Nomad

Ok, enjoy talking to yourself.

thisisnotanalt
offline
thisisnotanalt
9,821 posts
Farmer

Lol @ how only the newer people hate Klaus.

Anyway, tom, the reviews from IGN aren't flawed because they're opinion-based. The opinion presented in something opinion-based cannot be flawed because it's an opinion.

so really, it's not the review that's flawed, but your perception of their standpoint, their prerogative, and this situation as a whole.

Showing 31-45 of 54