ForumsWEPRHumour: When is a Joke not a Joke anymore.

32 8673
Pixie214
offline
Pixie214
5,838 posts
Peasant

There has been alot in the media recently about comedians and their joke that &quotush the envelope". Since the Summer and the Brand/Ross vs. Sachs radio debacle there have been a number of incidents where the jokes of comedians have been called into question. For example Frankie Boyle's joke about the Queen and Jimmy Carr's veterans/paralympics joke (look em up if you want their not rally appopriate for a PG13 site). So should comedians have free reign over material? Is it a case of if you don't like it don't listen? Or do comedians have a responsibility not to offend groups or individuals etc. Bear in mind new BBc guidelines would ahve meant some scenes from classic comedies like Fawltey Towers, Blackadder and The Office would be oulawed. What do you think?

  • 32 Replies
MageGrayWolf
offline
MageGrayWolf
9,462 posts
Farmer

believe in freedom so strongly if you want to go into the streets and shout N****r at every black man you see, I would support you for speaking your mind. I'm not gonna do it, or agree with you, but hey, "Freedom of Speech".
It's YOUR tongue and I'm not gonna metaphorically cut it off just because I don't agree with you or you offend me. Tv is offending. The internet is offending. Hell, life is offending. But it's not my place (or anyone elses) to say when to draw the line. As long as you aren't interfering with someone's freedom, go ahead.


While I agree with the sentiment I'm not to sure of your example. If a person was just out in the street yelling at others then those who don't want to hear it don't have the option to not listen. This in a way then infringes on others freedoms. Now if this person went on TV, Radio, Internet and decided to yell n****r then I would be fine with it. I don't have to hear it if I don't want to then.

Freedom of speech is given to those who do not deserve to be free, who would speak out against the very government that has granted them the freedom to do so. We have become too comfortable with our freedoms (which have been hard-earned). It's time to cut back.


How about we start by taking your freedoms away and we will see just how much your for this idea then.
Megamickel
offline
Megamickel
902 posts
Peasant

How about we start by taking your freedoms away and we will see just how much your for this idea then.

Typical anti-reform drama... The fact of the matter is that Freedom of Speech has been taken away again, and the Supreme Court of the time ruled it constitutional. I applaud them, and wish it could happen today in the modern climate of "OMG HUMAN RIGHTS PRISONERS NEED CHOCOLATE CAKE!"
LethalScout
offline
LethalScout
39 posts
Nomad

If logic, math, and/or science are used to back up a joke.
It's not mean if it's true.
If you are just voicing your opinion and it is false or offensive, sure you are protected by the constitution but unless new valid information is learned then it is never true or right.

Nurvana
offline
Nurvana
2,520 posts
Farmer

It's probably not funny anymore when nobody's laughing.

LordofAges
offline
LordofAges
21 posts
Shepherd

A joke is no longer a joke when the teller means more harm than humor.

MageGrayWolf
offline
MageGrayWolf
9,462 posts
Farmer

Typical anti-reform drama... The fact of the matter is that Freedom of Speech has been taken away again, and the Supreme Court of the time ruled it constitutional. I applaud them, and wish it could happen today in the modern climate of "OMG HUMAN RIGHTS PRISONERS NEED CHOCOLATE CAKE!"


Hmm, let me guess there's no establishing a dialog with you is there?
TSL3_needed
offline
TSL3_needed
5,579 posts
Nomad

What do you call two Mexicans playing basketball? Juan on Juan.

I just had to say that XD

A joke is no longer a joke when the teller means more harm than humor.


Which makes the above joke a joke. I mean humor, not harm.

Now Immma get called racist XD
Pixie214
offline
Pixie214
5,838 posts
Peasant

Now Immma get called racist XD


You sir are a racist.

There are some interesting points coming up though since very few of you are COMPLETELY INSANE they're generally in favouri of the freedom of cemedians. I thnk their will always be some one out there who finds dark comedy funny; after all their are whole (brilliant) websites dedicated to them.

"I saw a newspaper headline that read 'Man Held After Rape' I though 'my god!! he cuddled'"

One of my favourite jokes and only aprtially because I saw a newspaper headline like that and laughed... in the middle of a crowded newspaper store >_> they hated me lol.
balerion07
offline
balerion07
2,837 posts
Peasant

What did the Mexican Fireman name his two sons?

Hose a and Hose b.

TSL3_needed
offline
TSL3_needed
5,579 posts
Nomad

You sir are a racist.


NO I'M NOT! *huddles in a corner crying*

"I saw a newspaper headline that read 'Man Held After ****' I though 'my god!! he cuddled'"

One of my favourite jokes and only aprtially because I saw a newspaper headline like that and laughed... in the middle of a crowded newspaper store >_> they hated me lol.


That's, my friend, is hilarious XD

What did the Mexican Fireman name his two sons?

Hose a and Hose b.


lol?
Carbill66
offline
Carbill66
43 posts
Nomad

a couple of jokes will last forever but spell pig backwards then say pretty colors

goumas13
offline
goumas13
4,752 posts
Grand Duke

A joke is always a joke when you are drunk. When you are not it depends from the person who says it , the person who hears it and the reactions of the persons near him if there are any.

Freakenstein
offline
Freakenstein
9,504 posts
Jester

Never take this Chinese class...



See me A.S.A.P. - Kum Hia Nao

Small Horse - Tai Ni Po Ni

Your price is too high - No Bai Dam Deng

Did you go to the beach - Wai Yu So Tan

I bumped into a coffee table - Ai Bang Mai Ni

I think you need a facelift - Chen Tu Fat

It's very dark in here - Wai So Dim?

Has your flight been delayed? - Hao Long Wei Ting?

That was an unauthorized execution.- Lin Ching

I thought you were on a diet - Wai Yu Mun Ching?

This is a tow away zone. - No Pah King

You are not very bright - Yu So Dum

I got this for free - Ai No Pei

I am not guilty - Wai Hang Mi?

Please, stay a while longer - Wai Go Nao?

Our meeting was scheduled for next week - Wai Yu Kum Nao

They have arrived - Hia Dei Kum

Stay out of sight - Lei Lo

He's cleaning his automobile - Wa Shing Ka

Does this bathroom stink? - Hu Flung Dung?

314d1
offline
314d1
3,817 posts
Nomad

It depends on the person you tell it to. Such as, if I told a joke that insulted one of my friends he whould be fine, but if I told a joke that insulted a mentally retarded person that can't understand the concept of joking then he whould probably get me in trouble...

Deth666
offline
Deth666
653 posts
Nomad

"Tragedy is when I cut my finger. Comedy is when I fall into an open sewer and die" Mel Brooks

Everyone have a different sense of humor. For example, i find cancer funny. I make no excuses i'm a horrible human being and more than likely am going to hell. Say what you want and do what you want but don't be surprised when someone calls you an a**hole and/or punches you in the face. People are allowed to tell any joke they want and your allowed to get pissed off at the guy because that's the beauty of not living in a police state.

One of my favorite jokes:

How does every racist joke start?

*looks over both his shoulders*

Showing 16-30 of 32