ForumsWEPRwas world war 2 nessesary?

79 11558
SirLegendary
offline
SirLegendary
16,586 posts
Duke

Hey,

Im asking you now, do you think world war 2 was needed or nessesary???

For me, i thought it was because i wouldnt wanna be ruled by one country or the germans.

  • 79 Replies
German3945
offline
German3945
996 posts
Nomad

You said that WWII was justified by the WWI treaty.

Which is different from WWII being fueled/influenced/started as a result of the WWI treaty.

Either way, or even without WWI ever happening, with such a scenario as the one prior to the France being invaded, Germany should have been apprehended.

Sargantfrosty
offline
Sargantfrosty
145 posts
Nomad

You said that WWII was justified by the WWI treaty.


No I didn't! I said WWII WAS CAUSED BY WWI EVENTS!!!

The word justified is not in there!

Dam dude. If WWI didn't happen the WWII war wouldn't have either. Well let me rephrase that. If it wasn't for Militarism, Alliances, Imperialism, Nationalism and Stupidity WWI or WWII wouldn't have happened.
German3945
offline
German3945
996 posts
Nomad

"So in a way WWII was not necessary, but WWI made it necessary."

well yes, WWII may not have happened if WWI hadn't, but we can't speculate that because we don't have a time machine. Not to mention, WWI was necessary.

but focusing on WWII itself, Germany's part could have easily been prevented if their very serious actions had been taken seriously by the other world leaders.

AlphaJmon
offline
AlphaJmon
19 posts
Farmer

wooo.... war sucks.

Kasic
offline
Kasic
5,552 posts
Jester

wooo.... war sucks.


That's helpful, now only if you were participating in the anti-war protest groups in the 70's.
tomertheking
offline
tomertheking
1,751 posts
Jester

and didn't have to attack France at all.


They attacked because they wanted revenge, so they did have to attack.
Pau11Wa11
offline
Pau11Wa11
527 posts
Nomad

well those who dont think it was are people who like the though of Hitler running all of Europe if not more of the world than that

75Greeno
offline
75Greeno
130 posts
Peasant

it really depends on how you look at it did it need to happen no did America need to get in it to stop it yes

German3945
offline
German3945
996 posts
Nomad

With the fuel of Hitler's hatred for Jews. Yes.

Very true.
and Germany's economy completely collapsed regardless of the money they owed the US.
The economy collapsing helped the development of the power behind Hitler's movement.
They attacked because they wanted revenge, so they did have to attack.

No.
WWI. The Germans never had a valid reason to invade France in WWI. The war was between Austria-Hungary and Serbia, only in those countries. If Germany had simply been supporting Austria-Hungary in the war, they would have sent troops to help with Austria-Hungary's war. Instead, they used the breakout of war to their advantage and invade France. They knew France/Britain/etc had a treaty, and that they would start a very large war.
Germany was not a complete scapegoat in WWI. Their actions were anything but necessary.

And just to remind people, the question is not whether we should have engaged in war after Germany invaded France (WWII). It is whether other countries (Britain/France especially) could have prevented WWII from being a major war breakout.
cowdude5055
offline
cowdude5055
106 posts
Peasant

I wouldn't mind the Germans, but the Nazis are not Ok. How dare you even ask this question. this disgusts me so much. Read a little bit, kid. It was too necessary, you uneducated little boy-thing. This really makes me mad

grimml
offline
grimml
879 posts
Nomad

WWII wasn't necessary... You want to know why? Because the world (Europe, America, Russia...) could have stopped Hitler before he got that powerfull. There were enough signs that showed what kind of person Hitler really was.

DrawdeNosfellot
offline
DrawdeNosfellot
30 posts
Peasant

Secondly, it pushed 50 million people off. In hindsight, it was necessary to a certain extent. Overpopulation.


This is a very good point this is what i think.
Darkroot
offline
Darkroot
2,763 posts
Peasant

WWII wasn't necessary... You want to know why? Because the world (Europe, America, Russia...) could have stopped Hitler before he got that powerfully. There were enough signs that showed what kind of person Hitler really was.


When do governments start caring about the morality of people and their ideals.
nonconformist
offline
nonconformist
1,101 posts
Nomad

well considering the fact that everyone thinks that countries should have stopped it i can easily prove this point to be useless. The fact was that countries didn't want to see another war happen so close to WW1. So everybody looked away from germany hoping the problem would go away.
Germany was in severe debt already because WW1 caused them to sign unrealistic treaties that almost bankrupted their country. Hitler used this to his advantage to come into power, and blamed former leaders for screwing their country over. So he made promises to fix these problems, and he did exactly that. The only reason Germany attacked France was to stop all the German workers from gathering gold and minerals for France, and to stop them having to pay France for WW1. This of course stopped Germany having to pay there WW1 debts, and allowed them to become stronger. While they were at this, they had re-united austria/hungary making them a big power already. So hitler did all he wanted already. Took back the space in poland so that his countries could re-unite again, and took over a major dominance that was causing their country to run into bankruptcy. Shortly after war started when Hitler threatened belgium.. This was only because Britain had a major treaty with them, and they finally realized what was going on.

I personally believe that WW2 should've happened. Germany was fighting for their rights to stop unrealistic treaties forcefully signed during ww1. So they of course fought back. But they took it too far. Kind of like those kids in schools who get bullied, and then end up loosing full control and killing a bunch of people.. Yea thats kinda how I see Germany during WW2. But either way, it was all of Europe, and all of North Americas fault for letting it get so bad. So in reality, we could have saved millions of lives in Europe and North America weren't so arogant.... But either way, we need a war every now and then just so we can keep the natural selection of things going through out the human race... just my opinion thow

whyismynametom
offline
whyismynametom
263 posts
Nomad

Hitler was to stop at nothing and before America got involved they where attacking supply ships using submarines, so war was inevitable, but people forget that Italy was also our enemy and japan, not only Germany, i think the war was necessary because the Germans broke the rules and where openly announcing their plans to take over the world, the AXIS VS. the ALLIES axis had Germany, japan, and Italy. allies included America Russia and Britain, with help from china also. basically it was inevitable and necessary, where safe from countries now aren't we?

Showing 31-45 of 79