ForumsWEPRCorrupted Education System

16 2945
EnterOrion
offline
EnterOrion
4,220 posts
Nomad

In my humble opinion, I really do find the education system in our country to be rather corrupted. Not in the pay-off-the-officials kind of way, but rather what we're aiming for. It all seems for naught.

The whole point is to get good grades and pass some stupid test at the end of the year that isn't even remotely difficult for someone with half a brain, and the entire curriculum revolves around that.

I've always though of education as something that you're supposed to learn by, not get good grades and hope you pass.

This also brings me to my next point: While a lot of people do get some kind of accelerated class, a lot don't. They don't learn anything and they're smarter than nearly everyone in the class. The sweep through every paper, every test, but don't learn anything new because they know it all. Nothing is remotely hard.

Which goes against what education is supposed to mean.

/rant

Thoughts?

  • 16 Replies
NoNameC68
offline
NoNameC68
5,043 posts
Shepherd

This also brings me to my next point: While a lot of people do get some kind of accelerated class, a lot don't. They don't learn anything and they're smarter than nearly everyone in the class. The sweep through every paper, every test, but don't learn anything new because they know it all. Nothing is remotely hard.


I disagree with you. I doubt many kids go into their classes knowing everything already. The kids who brush past all their homework and tests are generally those who are fast learners.

I think school is corrupt for a completely different reason. I know many intelligent kids who are far smarter than their classmates who fail a lot of their classes. That's the real problem facing many students.
Graham
offline
Graham
8,051 posts
Nomad

Effort is all a grade is.

Can you propose a better way of teaching a general populous?

aknerd
offline
aknerd
1,416 posts
Peasant

Effort is all a grade is.

I disagree. While there is a general correlation between effort and good grades, I think that the intelligence of the student and teaching methods of the teacher are far more important. I know plenty of people who try hard but get a D and others who slack but have over a 4.0 GPA.

I disagree with you. I doubt many kids go into their classes knowing everything already. The kids who brush past all their homework and tests are generally those who are fast learners.

You obviously haven't taken a basic gov class...

We spent about a month learning about checks and balances, which I think most people learned in elementary school.

And yes, this is a required class at my school.
Graham
offline
Graham
8,051 posts
Nomad

I think that the intelligence of the student and teaching methods of the teacher are far more important.


Everything is genetic and environmental. Just when it boils down, it's effort that determines your grade.
wolf1991
offline
wolf1991
3,437 posts
Farmer

The Canadian education system is the exact same way. You merely sit in class and have facts shoved down your throat. Furthermore, each person has a unique talent, something they are good at, for me it is writing, and yet there is nothing in school to help me hone this school, nothing to guide me. My creative writing class is filled with people who only know how to write essays. Another problem I find. English is solely focussed on essay writing, this is a SEVERE flaw, because English is so much more than writing essays. And I agree with the OP, I hardly try and I pass will an A- average.

Sassin
offline
Sassin
170 posts
Nomad

I think it is corrupt but thoughout the whole year you obviously learn something or else why would you be going to school.

kirby1243
offline
kirby1243
141 posts
Nomad

I lived in Iowa for 7 years and i found that education was amazing there. The teaching is great because the teachers actually care in your education. They will spend time with you to make sure that you really understand what's going on. Then i moved to georgia... and my honest opinion is that it's horriable. The teachers don't give a rat's butt about your education, they care about that dang pay-check. Teachers should be paid accodingly to their job, not how many hours they get.

NoNameC68
offline
NoNameC68
5,043 posts
Shepherd

We spent about a month learning about checks and balances, which I think most people learned in elementary school.


It's required in most high schools. If you tell me that everyone in your class knew everything already, I won't believe you for a moment.

I remember making the best grades in basic biology class. To me, it was easy. Most of it was review from stuff I learned in grade school. However, I didn't go in there remembering everything I had learned in the past. If I didn't already know everything, why was biology easy for me?

When I sat down and read the book, I instantly understood what was being said. When my teacher said something, I was able to keep up with him with ease. Granted, because everything was already crammed in my head from grade school, most of what I learned came from the teacher jogging my memory. "Oh yeah, I remember learning that!

I also made some of the best grades in my English class. I didn't know everything when I went in there. Heck, I didn't know anything about the topics that we learned. We focused on reading books. I didn't know who the great Gatsby or Holden Caufeild were. I have never read The Things they carried or The Jungle before walking into English class.

The class was easy for me, not because I already knew everything, but because I was able to pick up on everything so easily. Also, I love to read, and that's all we did in that class.

The sweep through every paper, every test, but don't learn anything new because they know it all. Nothing is remotely hard.


Maybe they did know everything, but I doubt it. I honestly think they had a better grasp for what they were learning, figured it out miles before anyone else, and only seemed to know everything.

I don't think the issue is that school is too easy, I think the issue is that school is boring.

And I agree with the OP, I hardly try and I pass will an A- average.


You agree with the OP because the school work is too easy?

My creative writing class is filled with people who only know how to write essays. Another problem I find. English is solely focussed on essay writing, this is a SEVERE flaw, because English is so much more than writing essays.


Although I agree with you, it has nothing to do with the issue presented by the OP.

The OP wants to be challenged. You want to learn something you are more interested in. Please keep that in mind.
NoNameC68
offline
NoNameC68
5,043 posts
Shepherd

Sorry for double posting, but this is my own problem with the education system. I didn't want this to be crammed with my above point.

Here's the problem with school. Everything is so focused on meeting a certain criteria. Where I come from, you had to take 3 PE classes. That's three semesters of mine that were wasted. General study is too broad.

Another issue I have is that schools are filled with kids who don't want to learn. That's why I failed a lot of my classes. I would sit in a classroom absolutely bored out of my mind. Rather than having to write a paper on something related to the class, I would have to do take notes and turn them in for a grade or spend my time doing in class assignments that the class did as a group. I would generally say "fuck this" and drift off in my own world because everything moved at such an INCREDIBLY SLOW PACE. I would grow anxious with every question that took ten minutes to answer.

I hated how some of my teachers, especially one of my math teachers, would teach for the whole class period only to give your assignment at the end of class. In fact, my math teacher wouldn't assign us homework until the bell rang. She would go on and on and on about stuff that everyone knew. Seriously, everyone told her they wanted their homework early, but she refused to negotiate.

I never failed high school and I didn't have to stay an extra year. I passed just enough classes to graduate. I would either get caught up through tedious work near the end of the semester or it was a class I actually enjoyed and felt like I was going somewhere.

Another reason why it was hard for me to pass a lot of my classes was because they were stressful. My school was build like a prison. You couldn't even open the fucking windows! It would be a nice day. Want fresh air? Okay, oh wait, you can't, because the windows don't open. Not only that, but there were other ridiculous rules that only stressed me out more.

******

So here's is my issue with this thread. Don't worry if the classes are easy or not. I found the easiest classes to be those that interested me or had interesting teachers. I understand where the OP is coming from, and I think the issue isn't that everything is too easy, but rather they are moving too slow and he's being forced to work a week on a project he could have done in a day. If I'm wrong, do correct me.

I skipped school for a whole week. I just didn't want to go. When I returned, they put me in ISD or In School Detention. I was placed in a room with other students. Nobody was allowed to talk and I had to stay in that room the whole day. It was one of the best days I have ever had my miserable senior year.

I missed a weeks worth of homework, I got all of it done in that one day with time to spare. My grades began to drop from then because I kept falling asleep during class or going off into my own world, bored that I must listen to the same lecture that I already understood the first time around.

If I could change the education system, I would simply make school a more enjoyable place. If people want to learn, everyone can just move on.

wolf1991
offline
wolf1991
3,437 posts
Farmer

That's what I was trying to get at, though I came at it the wrong way.

But I also feel that school is going about things the wrong way. If I had the ability to change the system I would make it that students have more freedom to learn what they wish to learn, I see little point in placing a student in a mathematics class if, despite all efforts, they continue to fail. They should pursue their own personal goals.

But yes, school needs to be more enjoyable. I can think of a lot of ways to make English classes more enjoyable, it's called allow creativity in a student's work. Science should allow students to actually experiment not some stupid lab from a text book where the result is already known. History just needs more engaging teachers. Ect, ect. Though I'm sure that math is a hopeless case unless you already enjoy it.

steevo15
offline
steevo15
1,562 posts
Peasant

I see little point in placing a student in a mathematics class if, despite all efforts, they continue to fail. They should pursue their own personal goals.


But, yet another problem is that most people these days (or at least from what I have seen in all the public schools, and even the private school that I'm in) is that people don't HAVE any goals. So if you let people go pursue their own goals, it would be back home sleeping in bed. As Noname said, if people want to learn then we can all move on. But as I've seen, most people don't even want to learn, they just want to go out and party and do drugs, get drunk, etc... There needs to be some way to inject that lost will to learn back into the students of today.

I always go into my classes with a positive attitude no matter how much I hate the subject and I try to take each assignment, looking at it in a way that I might like it. All others around me just endlessly complain about how "stupid" or &quotointless" these classes are.
aknerd
offline
aknerd
1,416 posts
Peasant

It's required in most high schools. If you tell me that everyone in your class knew everything already, I won't believe you for a moment.

There were quite a few people who really needed to take that class. But there were at least five of us who still remembered what we learned in elementary school, and got literally nothing from the class. While it was an entertaining class, I feel like I could have spent my time better.

I don't think the issue is that school is too easy, I think the issue is that school is boring

Ideally, of course, school would be challenging and exciting.
But if I had to choose, I would rather have school be difficult and boring than easy and exciting. I can deal with boredom. But if a class is too easy, than I feel like my time is being wasted. I start to obsess about how I would rather spend my time.

One of my favorite classes was AP Chem. In class, we usually just took notes all period. I find this to be extremely boring and pointless, so I would just play games on my calculator.

But when I got home, the challenge of figuring out chemistry problems would more than make up for the boredom experianced in class. I started to look forward to tests, because I would want to see how well I can perform under pressure. The fact that the test itself would be extremely boring was irrelevant.

However, I have noticed that many other people have a strong aversion to &quotowerpoint classes" (you know what I mean). I feel like they would be more motivated to learn if information was presented in a less excruciatingly boring way.

Personally, I would not stand for such a method if it sacrificed the level of difficulty of the class.
samy
offline
samy
4,871 posts
Nomad

*Hugs the OP*

You've no idea how much I agree with every single word you just said.

The education system in this country doesn't stress a basic understanding of society or the current world around us. We need to rethink every single aspect of what goes is taught and how it is taught.

wolf1991
offline
wolf1991
3,437 posts
Farmer

But, yet another problem is that most people these days (or at least from what I have seen in all the public schools, and even the private school that I'm in) is that people don't HAVE any goals. So if you let people go pursue their own goals, it would be back home sleeping in bed.


Engage the mind and you'll have a student willing to work. I find being force fed information highly ineffective. The curiculum needs to allow discussion, make sure students understand what is being taught and bring the focus into terms that are understandable and enjoyable.

Fun fact: The Chinese do not begin academics until the age of 7. From the ages of 4-6 (kindergarten) the system allows for children to express their creativity, this has later proven to show better stimulation in class as they grow up.
NoNameC68
offline
NoNameC68
5,043 posts
Shepherd

Ideally, of course, school would be challenging and exciting.
But if I had to choose, I would rather have school be difficult and boring than easy and exciting.


I'm pretty sure that is not true. You keep telling me you're this student who is bored with class because you keep passing everything with ease. I'm glad you're able to pass under such boring conditions. However, I doubt you would choose a hard boring class over a simple, fun class. I think the problem isn't that school is too easy, but that it moves at too slow a pace.

Maybe what makes a class hard differs between us. To me, a hard class is one that you find hard to pass for one reason or another. To you, it's a class that involves problems that are harder to solve and possibly a stricter grading curriculum.

If you find yourself unable to do homework, then the the problem is likely that you're too bored to do it, not that it's to hard.

I have always done bad in classes that I hated, no matter the difficulty. I know many people who also did bad in classes they didn't enjoy. The people who worked through their boredom never complained about their fun classes being too easy. Maybe they would say "I wish it was a bit more difficult," but in no way do I think they would rather take a difficult class that has no appeal to them.

Further, I should add, that no matter how hard a class is, if you have fun doing the work, chances are it's easy for you. It may be challenging, but the work itself isn't hard for you to handle at all.

Engage the mind and you'll have a student willing to work.


No. Play to a student's needs, and you will get him to work.

The thing about school being boring isn't so much the school education system , but the teachers. Most schools hire whoever they can at a fairly low price. Teachers are under payed. The experts who have their masters in their field of study and a teaching degree will generally turn down a job as a teacher if it isn't college that's hiring them.

If you're an A student and you're complaining that the work is too easy, then maybe it is. I doubt you would complain if it was enjoyable though. If you have an A and you're bored in class or the teacher keeps rambling about stuff you already know, then you need to start asking them more questions!
Showing 1-15 of 16