ForumsWEPRboy corrects N.A.S.A.

23 4517
shadedclan
offline
shadedclan
405 posts
Peasant

did you guy hear about a 13 year old boy corrects the prediction of N.A.S.A.?

  • 23 Replies
Moegreche
offline
Moegreche
3,826 posts
Duke

I just Googled it, but all of the news sources that presented the story were not reliable. Could this be a hoax?
I don't really get how a 13 year old German kid could get the astronomical data in order to be able to ascertain such calculations. Also, the prediction is about the Apophis asteroid, which this kid predicted a 1:450 chance of hitting Earth, as opposed to NASA's 1:45,000 chance.
That seems like a very odd probability difference - almost like NASA forgot to convert units or something. Of course, that's why they slammed that Mars Rover into Mars' surface the first time...

drainslug
offline
drainslug
48 posts
Nomad

no but as mogrech said probably a miscaluclation on someones part

Megamickel
offline
Megamickel
902 posts
Peasant

Yeah, but Moe, this is...
Woah, your post count is 666. Creepy.
Anyways, Moe, this would be a simple metric conversion, not like working with metric to imperial, where the difference would be more than a few zeros. Rather, it'd be a completely different number.

Even still, pure idiocy.

DaMasta333
offline
DaMasta333
359 posts
Nomad

this just prover that everyone's human...
we all make mistakes.

dirkpitt1
offline
dirkpitt1
1,281 posts
Nomad

i bet nasa is wetting their pants right now

Moegreche
offline
Moegreche
3,826 posts
Duke

No, I'm quite certain that this is a hoax now

dirkpitt1
offline
dirkpitt1
1,281 posts
Nomad

why? It dont sound like one to me

Dexavis
offline
Dexavis
15 posts
Peasant

I wouldn't consider 13 as boy, more like teenager. I doubt this really happened. I'm pretty sure that they would double-check their calculations all the time. Although anyone can make a simple mistake.

I read a news article awhile ago about a 10 year old that corrected a label at the Smithsonian Museum.

dirkpitt1
offline
dirkpitt1
1,281 posts
Nomad

I really hope this happened is too funny

Moegreche
offline
Moegreche
3,826 posts
Duke

[url=http://www.theregister.co.uk/2008/04/16/esa_german_schoolboy_apophis_denial/]

That's a link to an article claiming that the kid's numbers were wrong. I still don't think there was a kid that was actually calculating anything, though.

Calm
offline
Calm
908 posts
Herald

I totally agree with Moe here. This entire story seems highly improbable to me...

shadedclan
offline
shadedclan
405 posts
Peasant

although it would still be possible because nobody is perfect am i right?

nick_coolhaha
offline
nick_coolhaha
1,191 posts
Herald

Well, anything is possible, well kind of, but I also agree that this isn't true. Also, DaMasta, sure we all make mistakes, but I really doubt that NASA should me making mistakes because that's how they get people killed haha. Slight miscaculations and BOOM the rocket is in a thousnad peices.

SerbWarrior
offline
SerbWarrior
38 posts
Nomad

Well i think it is posible...
Um...
The kid said the chances are 1:450 and NASA said 1:45.000...
I think its very possible since NASA as a govermant institution will lie to people to make them calm,and not panic...
But he is a 13 year old...
I dont get how one kid can make those calculations....
Also 1:45.000 sure as hell looks better than 1:450
Is it possible that you are lying to your selves for the hope of the better?

DecadentDragon
offline
DecadentDragon
242 posts
Nomad

As it turns out, boy was wrong.

Showing 1-15 of 23