ForumsWEPRmicrosoft being sued by african american

28 9562
skater_kid_who_pwns
offline
skater_kid_who_pwns
4,375 posts
Blacksmith

So I am sure you have all heard of the microsofts newest toy, the xbox kinect.

The way it works, is light with reflected off the player, back at the sensor, and it detects movements that way. Well, if darker clothing is worn, it is absorbed.

The same is true, for dark skin.

An African American is sueing microsoft for racsim, beacsue it doesn't work since there skin absors the light. This isn't a rasict gesture, just the laws of light. Dark colors absorb light.

I can't give a link to a news article, as I can not find one. however, a quick google search brings up a large page of this story.

I find the case rediculous and think it should not be seen as an injustice.

What are your thoughts?

  • 28 Replies
Alexander116
offline
Alexander116
107 posts
Shepherd

I don't think anyone is going to take the African Americans side on this one. haha, it pretty ridiculous to think that Microsoft purposely made there device to exclude black people.

Avorne
offline
Avorne
3,085 posts
Nomad

-sigh- you'd think the guy wouldn't win but I remember the case of a certain type of motion tracking webcam (I think) that couldn't track dark skin and the judge ruled in the favour of the guy suing.

314d1
offline
314d1
3,817 posts
Nomad

"Your machine is racist against me!"....

Just were a long sleeve light colored shirt...

skater_kid_who_pwns
offline
skater_kid_who_pwns
4,375 posts
Blacksmith

"Your machine is racist against me!"....
Just were a long sleeve light colored shirt...


Yes, but that white man doesnt have to wear special clothing to play this game!

It's an argument as racial descrimination. Simple thigns like that won't solve the case.
Moe
offline
Moe
1,714 posts
Blacksmith

Bill Gates doesn't own Microsoft anymore.

As for this lawsuit, its something that shouldn't happen. But people seem to think that anything they can think is a problem is reason to sue.

NoNameC68
offline
NoNameC68
5,043 posts
Shepherd

Even if the motion tracker didn't work on blacks, Microsoft should not be sued. If it was proven that blacks could not use the Kinect, I'm sure Microsoft would try to fix the problem because they want customers. Regardless, there's no such thing as accidental racism and if Microsoft didn't intentionally plan for the Kinect to have problems with blacks, then they should not be able to get sued.

Anyway, it is clear that the Kinect does not have any problems when detecting blacks. I heard there's some problems with facial recognition, but it's not a feature many games are likely going to use.

Here's one example where the Kinect works for people with dark skin.

PrideRage
offline
PrideRage
148 posts
Nomad

What I've heard is that Kinect uses two 3D Depth Sensors (I think infrared based) and one RGB camera. So it actually can't be true that blacks are neglect.

Faunbard
offline
Faunbard
650 posts
Nomad

i think microsoft wasnt thinking, but it is the law of light. If i could talk to the african american guy, i would tell him to buy a wii, or a playstation move

SubZero131
offline
SubZero131
598 posts
Nomad

Considering I just got the red ring of death I am siding with this black dude. Also about that, It was working fined the night before, but my buddy brought his hard drive over and plugged it in, started up the game and then the screen pixleated. Now I am getting red ring of death even though it was only on for a couple minutes. What the Hell?

Secretmapper
offline
Secretmapper
1,747 posts
Nomad

That is retard. It's laws of light, it's not as though microsoft did it intentionally.

Roadripper
offline
Roadripper
1,514 posts
Farmer

It sucks that he will probably never be able to play Kinect (although why would anyone want to). Did nobody think of that?! O_O

~RR~

BenTheBozer
offline
BenTheBozer
815 posts
Nomad

It just shows that people think can sue over anything.

Somers
offline
Somers
1,532 posts
Nomad

Did anyone laugh their *** off when they first heard this? Just me? ok...

And sueing over it? Its ridiculous.

logantheking
offline
logantheking
254 posts
Scribe

People are so lawsuit-happy these days, especially if there is a minority or evil large corporations. If the system truly did not work for darker skin color then there are ways to remedy it, wearing a white shirt, enhancing the sensor, body-paint etc.

Also, would kinect not work if the room is dark?

MoonFairy
offline
MoonFairy
3,386 posts
Shepherd

I don't believe they would let this guy win....
I mean, yes it sucks, but suing for racism is wrong. They weren't in their little brainstorm room saying
"ooooo lets make sure that it only can see white people an not black because i hate black people."

Yeah, NO. I don't see that.

Showing 1-15 of 28