ForumsGamesVGA results

22 4917
d_dude
offline
d_dude
3,523 posts
Peasant

I've been dissapointed now for two years in a row. Last year Uncharted wins. (sorry uncharted fans but we Xbox owners don't happen to play PS3 exclusives) Then this year Red Dead Redemption beats Halo Reach (oh and Black Ops). WTF?! How is Red Dead better than Reach? This is an outrage. I will find the people who are responsible for this, then strap them down to tables. I will then burn off their little game of the year picker toes. Next I will shoot nails into their arms. Finally I will shove chopsticks all the way through their eyes.


That was a bit too.....violent? Creepy? Anyways, the only award that made me happy was Action Adventure game of the year which was won by Assassin's Creed Brotherhood.

So what did you think of the results? Do you want to burn some toes off too?

  • 22 Replies
ChillzMaster
offline
ChillzMaster
1,434 posts
Nomad

I was mostly happy with the results, and happy that Black Ops lost GOTY, i loved all the games nominated (excluding Black Ops) and Red Dead was one of my favorite games of all time. Still think Halo should have won, but whatevs.

Also - best character is Sgt. Woods? I THINK NOT! obviously the best was Kratos!

hobgoblin3
offline
hobgoblin3
455 posts
Nomad

At least Black ops didnt won Best multiplayer, the awar went to Haloand im happy because this new cod multiplayer is a copy paste of the mw2 multiplayer but this time balanced and not ridulous

Kyouzou
offline
Kyouzou
5,061 posts
Jester

Red Dead definitely deserved the award, why?

It was a completely new genre, Rockstar has never really had any games of that caliber released, i.e. it had no backing from previous games.

Call of Duty, Halo, God of War all have massive franchises behind them, Red Dead had , dare I say unprecedented success for a brand new game.

That said, I would've picked Ezio or Kratos as character of the year. Woods was not that amazing.

spacedingo
offline
spacedingo
243 posts
Nomad

Red Dead sounded like a fun game. For Character of the Year I frankly would've picked Ellis or Ezio.

crimsonblade55
offline
crimsonblade55
5,399 posts
Shepherd

Red Dead definitely deserved the award, why?

It was a completely new genre, Rockstar has never really had any games of that caliber released, i.e. it had no backing from previous games.

Call of Duty, Halo, God of War all have massive franchises behind them, Red Dead had , dare I say unprecedented success for a brand new game.


Well actually it wasn't a completely new IP, it was based on a game called Red Dead Revolver, and while it wasn't a sequel story wise, it brought back some of the ideas from the original, so it already had some sort of footing, and the fact that it basically was GTA in a different setting doesn't help either. If it was an unheard of company with a new IP(such as the original Half-Life I suppose) then I would be surprised.
Outstanding
offline
Outstanding
75 posts
Peasant

Personally, I love Red Dead. I spent so long playing that. Every day to my mom I was like, "Red Dead?" and I kept bugging her until you she went and bought it for me. Ah, good times...

StrategicCaptain
offline
StrategicCaptain
393 posts
Nomad

I Don't really like Red Dead! But I Played It A Bit and Good graphics and music but just not the game for me. I Prefer Call Of Duty Or Halo!

spacedingo
offline
spacedingo
243 posts
Nomad

Personally, I love Red Dead. I spent so long playing that. Every day to my mom I was like, "Read Dead?" and I kept bugging her until you she went and bought it for me. Ah, good times...

Maybe I should start doing that...
Kyouzou
offline
Kyouzou
5,061 posts
Jester

@CB

Revolver, too date sold only 1.5 million copies, while Redemption has already sold over 5 million.

Granted the GTA influence does give it some backing, however GTA is set in a much more modern setting providing players with huge varieties of weapons and transportation. Something that when it first came out was probably a huge detractor for the GTA fans.

delossantosj
offline
delossantosj
6,672 posts
Nomad

and it begins.....

Last year Uncharted wins.


go to your friends house, play it on HIS/HER playstation then come to me and say any other game deserved to win over that game.

Then this year Red Dead Redemption beats Halo Reach (oh and Black Ops)


im honestly dissapointed in the games that have come out this year overall. i mean RDR wasnt THAT amazing considering the originallity of it was 0/10. oh and black ops didnt even deserve the nomination let alone a win XD

Assassin's Creed Brotherhood.

COMPLETLY retarded considering it wasnt nominated for game of the year, when god of war was. contradiction much?

i believe that god of war was the ONLY good good game nominated in anything XD and i have played pretty much EVERY nomination, so im deffinatly not one sided.

i think people need to except that ps3 has the best games now. but really.... RDR game of the year? what a joke. god of war smashed EVERY video game on that list.

also i feel starcraft should have won best multiplayer considering the cult following it has.

if RDR would have won best graphics i would have shot myself cause that game shouldnt even have been nominated.
kacboy
offline
kacboy
1,846 posts
Nomad

Sure Halo and CoD are popular, but think, are they really all that, coming out almost every year. They are just the super popular over-rated games right now, but think are they really that epic? Before it was like Halo 3 and MW1, then Halo ODST and MW2, now Halo Reach and Black Ops. They're just common but popular games nowadays.

Red Dead totally deserved it out of what was nominated from Spike.

Outstanding
offline
Outstanding
75 posts
Peasant

Personally, I have played almost all the games on the list. Red Dead deserved to win. Black ops rating = 9.0 Halo Reach rating = 9.5
Red Dead Redemption rating = 9.75

Thanks to GameInformer for these ratings. Clearly Red Dead was the best out of ratings, but if you played it. You would know why.

delossantosj
offline
delossantosj
6,672 posts
Nomad

Personally, I have played almost all the games on the list. Red Dead deserved to win. Black ops rating = 9.0 Halo Reach rating = 9.5
Red Dead Redemption rating = 9.75


god of war 3=10 can you seriously with this that RDR deserved to win. what a joke.
kacboy
offline
kacboy
1,846 posts
Nomad

Thanks to GameInformer for these ratings. Clearly Red Dead was the best out of ratings, but if you played it. You would know why.


god of war 3=10 can you seriously with this that RDR deserved to win. what a joke.

I don't trust just one sites rankings, use GameRankings for stuff like this.

God of War III - 92.07%
Red Dead Redemption - 94.76%
As of 12.13.10
delossantosj
offline
delossantosj
6,672 posts
Nomad

RDR had pretty much no originallity to it at all. i mean yes it was a good game but come on god of war three was just plain out GENIOUS. a true work of art

Showing 1-15 of 22