ForumsPopular MediaIs Jimi Hendrix a Little too Overrated?

45 10757
bacobit
offline
bacobit
1,671 posts
Nomad

I'm not saying the guy wasn't a Great Guitarist, He deffinatly had huge influence on Music and his improvs were great. But, to be honest, I don't think he's thee Single greatest guitarist ever, he's way up there, sure, But not the greatest.
I know I'm going to get some bad feedback, but I can take it.

  • 45 Replies
bacobit
offline
bacobit
1,671 posts
Nomad

Posted Jan 1, '11 at 5:46pm

GreatestSoloEver
1,149 posts

Flag
I see much ignorance in this thread...

If you are a guitar player or even have any sense of guitar playing you would understand the reasons that make up the essence of why Jimi Hendrix is one of the greatest guitarists of all time...

Case Closed


No one said he wasn't good, just a little overrated, he's in the top five on my my list. A better tittle for this, I relies now, would be "Is Jimi Hendrix the Number One Guitarist of all Time?"
crazyfrogbg
offline
crazyfrogbg
58 posts
Peasant

he is overrated because he deserves. but particularly my favorite is buckethead. but I understand that jimi always be number one. (:

skater_kid_who_pwns
offline
skater_kid_who_pwns
4,375 posts
Blacksmith

Compared to the way artists are over rated today? No.


Eminem, lil wayne, other terrible artists are all overrated. There the big artists today, so people blow them way out of proportion.

Fyrefox
offline
Fyrefox
2,124 posts
Blacksmith

"I can learn that in an hour" Skill
True, I learned most of Nirvana's "Nevermind" album in a couple days, but playing left-handed is a bit difficult. He's one of the greatest left-handed guitarist I know.

Now back on topic about Jimi... Personally I think there are better guitarists out there than him, but he was definitely an extraordinary guitarist. He had solid riffs, awesome solos, and great passion for the guitar.

Although I think influence ranks him high on most lists, I believe they're better guitarist than him. Is he overrated? I don't think so. If I'm not mistaken, Jimi also played left-handed?
Kevin4762
offline
Kevin4762
2,420 posts
Nomad

True, I learned most of Nirvana's "Nevermind" album in a couple days, but playing left-handed is a bit difficult. He's one of the greatest left-handed guitarist I know.

Now back on topic about Jimi... Personally I think there are better guitarists out there than him, but he was definitely an extraordinary guitarist. He had solid riffs, awesome solos, and great passion for the guitar.


This. Also, I didn't know Kurt was left handed.
delossantosj
offline
delossantosj
6,672 posts
Nomad

yes i didnt know kurt was a lefty, but jimi was known for being a lefty

blue98
offline
blue98
10 posts
Nomad

In my opinion, I don't think so. He is very skilled and his music isn't that bad. I don't care for it but that doesn't mean he isn't good at what he does.

DesertHyena
offline
DesertHyena
2,886 posts
Peasant

I honestly agree, I think Jimi Hendrix is overrated. I find his music to sound like "stoner" music(by which I mean the music itself sounds stoned), and "Purple Haze" is the perfect example of this. I think he sounds ok, but I would certainly never put him on my list of bands I recognize (see my prof).

Fyrefox
offline
Fyrefox
2,124 posts
Blacksmith

I find his music to sound like "stoner" music(by which I mean the music itself sounds stoned), and "Purple Haze" is the perfect example of this. I think he sounds ok, but I would certainly never put him on my list of bands I recognize (see my prof).
Well, I kinda agree with that statement, but it was basically the "new wave" in rock at the time. That genre was called psychedelic rock, back when just about everyone did LSD. Although that drug isn't as popular now, if majorly effected music. Keep in mind this was music that was recorded decades ago. Of course it's not gonna sound like modern music.
DesertHyena
offline
DesertHyena
2,886 posts
Peasant

I'm all too aware of that (seriously,. look at the list on my profile), but what I mean is that out of all the Psychedelic rock, Jimi Hendrix is the one guy who doesn't really seem that way to me. And yes, I am aware that almost every single major band has used some kind of drug (except "Weird" Al Yankovic and maybe Tom Petty, not sure about him, but he does smoke...)

jroyster22
offline
jroyster22
755 posts
Peasant

Jimi is the man! He had to play a right handed guitar upside down to play with his left hand. That Takes talent which most likely means he was self taught. Truly amazing.

bacobit
offline
bacobit
1,671 posts
Nomad

Jimi is the man! He had to play a right handed guitar upside down to play with his left hand. That Takes talent which most likely means he was self taught. Truly amazing


But he restrung it, he didn't play the strings upside down. The only real problem that could arise from that is the cutaway doesn't allow access to higher frets.
Fyrefox
offline
Fyrefox
2,124 posts
Blacksmith

Jimi is the man! He had to play a right handed guitar upside down to play with his left hand. That Takes talent which most likely means he was self taught. Truly amazing.[quote]But he restrung it, he didn't play the strings upside down. The only real problem that could arise from that is the cutaway doesn't allow access to higher frets.
[/quote] Also using the tremolo would be a little awkward. Unless he played on something with a double cutaway like a Gibson SG or something with generally low action that wouldn't be too difficult. I think he only used a Stratocaster (mostly), but if you've listened to most of his songs, they don't go really high anyways. So he probably didn't even go near the cutaway.
wezzeldurf
offline
wezzeldurf
27 posts
Peasant

I dont agree he is overrated, i think u are missing the point why is he considered the best guitarist. Its not because of the speed of playing or technics, its because he expanded the way u can play or look at that instrument. He introduced guitar feedback (the high sound of the guitar when put close to the amp) and he even modified his own pedals and invented some, like Octavio and modified Wah-wah fuzz pedal. He influenced lots of the music to came after him, the whole alternative noise guitar playing (sonic youth, nirvana, butthole-surfers, spaceman 3 etc.) So i think he has his Throne for a reason.

delossantosj
offline
delossantosj
6,672 posts
Nomad

truley the greatest overall rock guitarist i think is the proper thing to say, because i could name many guitarist outside of the genre to be more influential and overall better then him.

Showing 16-30 of 45